Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Dunkeld-29
H 		1205 Ada gravin van Holland Dunkeld before 1143 uncertain Scotland after 11 Jan 1207 Female WikiTree-65
Q2483091 Ada of Huntingdon (Scottish noblewoman) 1146 Huntingdon United Kingdom 1205 1206 Middelburg Netherlands female
Stewart-2514
H 		6 Jul 1435 Sir Alexander 12th Earl of Mar Stewart 1370 Lochindorb castle, Badenoch, Scotland 25 Jul 1435 Mar, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q2834058 Alexander Stewart, Earl of Mar (Scottish nobleman) 14cen 6 Jul 1435 male
Brus-99
H 		9 Feb 1307 Alexander de Brus (Brus) aka Bruce, Brewes 1282 Carrick, Scotland 17 Feb 1307 Carlisle, Cumberland, England Male WikiTree-65
Q4720472 Alexander de Brus (Scottish noble) 1285 9 Feb 1307 male
Lindsay-1321
H 		1311 Sir Alexander Lindsay uncertain 1267 Breneville, Ayrshire, Scotland uncertain 1314 Crawford, Clydesdale, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q18670690 Alexander Lindsay of Barnweill (Scottish nobleman) 1267 1311 male
Stewart-1007
H 		24 Jul 1394 Alexander The Wolf of Badenoch Stewart Earl of Buchan (Stewart) uncertain 1343 certain Dundonald, Ayrshire, Scotland 4 Apr 1406 certain Dundonald, Ayrshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q1358975 Alexander Stewart, Earl of Buchan (Scottish nobleman) 1343 24 Jul 1394 20 Jun 1405 Perth and Kinross United Kingdom male
Lennox-71
H 		1216 Alwyn Alwyn the Younger Lennox Second Earl of Lennox (Lennox) after 1160 Lennox, Scotland before 4 Dec 1214 uncertain Dunbartonshire, Scotland Male Cochoit-2

WikiTree-65
Q4697107 Ailín II, Earl of Lennox (Scottish Earl) 1216 1217 male
Stewart-1621
H 		1541 Andrew Stewart aka The Bishop of Caithness uncertain 1485 Balveny, Fife, Scotland 1542 Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q4758646 Andrew Stewart (Bishop of Caithness) 14cen 1541 Dornoch United Kingdom male
Douglas-404
H 		24 Dec 1400 Sir Archibald The Grim Douglas Third Earl of Douglas (Douglas) uncertain 1328 uncertain Scotland uncertain 23 Dec 1400 certain Thrieve Castle, Kirkcudbrightshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q592380 Archibald Douglas, 3rd Earl of Douglas (3rd Earl of Douglas) 1328 Scotland United Kingdom 24 Dec 1400 Threave Castle United Kingdom male
MacAlpin-18
H 		1058 Boete Bodhe McAlpin (MacAlpin) uncertain 990 Atholl, Perth, Scotland after 1033 Male Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q335885 Boite mac Cináeda (11th-century Scottish prince) 985 1058 male
Mac Echdach-4
H 		660 Conall Crandomna mac Echdach after 600 Dal Riata (now Western Scotland) uncertain 659 Dál Riata Male WikiTree-65

Harper-1691
Q879099 Conall Crandomna (King of Dal Riata) 06000101 660 male
Stewart-966
H 		1386 David Stewart Earl Palatine of Strathern and Caithness (Stewart) 1357 Dundonald, Ayrshire, Scotland uncertain 5 Mar 1389 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Stewart-6071

WikiTree-65
Q4444832 David Stewart, Earl of Strathearn (Scottish Earl) 1357 1386 male
Mar-35
H 		11 Aug 1332 Domhnall Domhnall II Donald, Earl of Mar, Regent of Scotland Mar uncertain 1294 Saline, Fifeshire, Scotland 12 Aug 1332 Dupplin Moor, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q1237391 Domhnall II, Earl of Mar (14th-century Scottish nobleman) 1302 11 Aug 1332 11 Aug 1332 male
Carrick-163
H 		13 Jun 1250 Duncan de Carrick Earl of Carrick (Carrick) before 1164 Carrick, Ayrshire, Scotland certain 13 Jun 1252 Argyll, Clan, Fife, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q1241816 Donnchadh, Earl of Carrick (Gall-Gaidhil prince and Scottish magnate) 12cen Dumfries and Galloway United Kingdom 13 Jun 1250 male
Dunkeld-78
H 		8 Jan 1107 Edgar Edgar I King of Scots (Dunkeld) uncertain 1074 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland certain 6 Jan 1107 certain Edinburgh Castle, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q332140 Edgar (King of Scotland (1074-1107)) 1074 8 Jan 1107 8 Jan 1107 Edinburgh United Kingdom male
Beaumont-163
H 		11 Feb 1234 Ermengarde Queen of Scots (Beaumont) uncertain 1158 Beaumont-le-Vicomte, Maine, France certain 11 Feb 1233 Balmerino Abbey, Fife, Fifeshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q2569718 Ermengarde de Beaumont (Queen of Scotland) 1170 11 Feb 1234 Kingdom of Scotland Kingdom of Scotland female
Ross-649
H 		1386 Queen Euphemia Countess of Moray (Ross) uncertain 1329 Cromarty Castle, Cromartyshire, Scotland uncertain 1387 Paisley Chapel, Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Stewart-6071
Q271445 Euphemia de Ross (Scottish royal consort) 1333 Cromarty Castle United Kingdom 1386 Scotland United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 09.02.2022 03:51:42 Comment No credible sources located indicating d.o.d.
Balliol-54
H 		1274 Eustace Balliol 1208 Aberdeen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland after 1278 Male WikiTree-65
Q76286531 Eustace de Balliol (Peerage person ID=663322) 1274 male
De Lawedre-12
H 		1426 George de Lawedre aka Provost of Edinburgh uncertain 1373 Haltoun Castle, Ratho, Edinburghshire, Scotland uncertain 1430 Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Q5546686 George de Lawedre of Haltoun (Scottish diplomat) 1351 1426 male
Douglas-421
H 		12 Mar 1463 George Fourth Earl of Angus (Douglas) uncertain 1427 Mar, Aberdeenshire, Scotland 14 Nov 1462 Abernethy, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q359632 George Douglas, 4th Earl of Angus (Scottish earl and diplomat) 1417 12 Mar 1463 male
Sigurdsson-45
H 		891 Guttorm Sigurdsson aka Jarl of Orkney uncertain 871 Orkney, Orkney Islands, Scotland uncertain 893 Male WikiTree-65

Bairfield-1
Q2416251 Guthorm Sigurdsson (871 - est. 893) 881 891 male
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Sinclair-96
H 		1420 Sir Henry Sinclair Second Earl of Orkney (Sinclair) uncertain 1375 uncertain Rosslyn Castle, Edinburghshire, Scotland uncertain 1 Feb 1419 uncertain Orkney Islands, Orkney, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q3132853 Henry II Sinclair (Earl of Orkney) 1375 1420 male
Stewart-1203
H 		26 Oct 1460 Isabel Murray (Stewart) aka Oliphant uncertain 1393 Scotland after 1445 Tullibardine, Blackford, Perthshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75268603 Isabel Stewart (Peerage person ID=25156) 1388 26 Oct 1460 female
Stewart-1865
H 		13 Oct 1494 Isabella Elizabeth, Isabel of Scotland (Stewart) uncertain 1426 Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1498 France Female WikiTree-65
Q2377156 Isabella of Scotland, Duchess of Brittany (Scottish princess; second child of James I of Scotland and Joan Beaufort) 1426 Perth United Kingdom 13 Oct 1494 Vannes France female
Mar-7
H 		12 Dec 1296 Lady Isabella Matilda Mar Countess of Carrick (Mar) aka de Brus, de Bruce, Brewes uncertain 1278 certain Kildrummy, Aberdeenshire, Scotland before 1302 uncertain Dumbarton, Dunbartonshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Hamilton-4105

Wright-7062
Q444026 Isabella of Mar (first wife of Robert the Bruce) 1277 12 Dec 1296 female
Huntingdon-10
H 		1251 Isabelle de Bruce (Huntingdon) aka de Brus, of Huntingdon 1199 Huntingdon, Huntingdonshire, England 1252 Saltre Abbey, Huntingdonshire, England Female WikiTree-65
Q6085344 Isobel of Huntingdon (Wife of Robert de Brus, 4th Lord of Annandale) 1199 Huntingdon United Kingdom 1251 female
Douglas-425
H 		5 Aug 1388 Sir James Douglas Second Earl of Douglas and Mar (Douglas) 1355 Douglas Castle, Lanarkshire before 18 Aug 1388 Northumberland, England Male WikiTree-65
Q586953 James Douglas, 2nd Earl of Douglas (Scottish noble) 1358 Scotland United Kingdom 5 Aug 1388 Otterburn United Kingdom male
Stewart-13721
H 		1329 Sir John de Menteith (Stewart) uncertain 1265 Kerse, Renfrewshire, Scotland after 1323 Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q12858658 John de Menteith (Scottish nobleman) 1275 Perthshire United Kingdom 1329 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 26.03.2020 14:01:16 Corrected
Stewart-2351
H 		21 Feb 1429 Sir John First Lord of Aubigny (Stewart) aka Stuart uncertain 1380 certain Darnley, Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 12 Feb 1429 certain Rouvray, France Male WikiTree-65

Stuart-531
Q3182538 John Stewart of Darnley (Scottish nobleman and soldier of the Hundred Years War) 1380 Scotland United Kingdom 21 Feb 1429 Rouvray-Sainte-Croix France male
Graham-635
H 		28 Feb 1347 Sir John Graham Earl of Menteith (Graham) uncertain 1290 Strathblane, Lanarkshire, Scotland Mar 1347 London, Middlesex Male WikiTree-65
Q6235932 John Graham, Earl of Menteith ((died 1347)) 28 Feb 1347 male
Lennox-73
H 		1250 Maldouen de Levenax Third Earl of Lennox (Lennox) before 1187 uncertain Inchmurrin Isle, Loch Lomond, Dunbartonshire, Scotland after 12 Mar 1251 uncertain Balloch Castle, Loch Lomond, Dunbartonshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q6753634 Maol Domhnaich, Earl of Lennox (Scottish noble) 1250 male
Strathearn-32
H 		1329 Sir Malise Seventh Earl of Strathearn (Strathearn) uncertain 1278 Strathearn, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1327 Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q6753645 Maol Íosa IV (Mormaer of Strathearn) 12cen 1329 male
Wake-3
H 		19 Sep 1349 Margaret Countess of Kent, Lady Wake Comyn (Wake) aka of Liddel uncertain 1299 Liddel Strength, Cumberland, England 29 Sep 1349 Liddel Strength, Cumberland, England Female WikiTree-65
Q3846893 Margaret Wake, 3rd Baroness Wake of Liddell (English Baron) 1300 Cumberland United Kingdom 19 Sep 1349 female
Lennox-196
H 		1364 Lady Margaret Faslane (Lennox) uncertain 1320 Balloch Castle, Loch Lomond, Dunbartonshire, Scotland uncertain 19 Aug 1388 Balloch Castle, Loch Lomond, Dunbartonshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q6759120 Margaret, Countess of Lennox (Scottish noble) 1364 female
Dunkeld-61
H 		9 Apr 1283 Margaret Queen consort of Norway (Dunkeld) certain 28 Feb 1261 certain Windsor Castle, Berkshire, England 12 Apr 1283 Tønsberg, Vestfold, Norway Female Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q235482 Margaret of Scotland (Queen of Norway) Mar 1261 Windsor Castle United Kingdom 9 Apr 1283 Tønsberg Municipality Norway female
Stewart-556
H 		1520 Princess Margaret Stewart after 1336 Dundonald, Ayrshire, Scotland 1410 Cromarty, Cromartyshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75385091 Margaret Stewart (Scottish princess) 1520 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 17.02.2022 05:57:29 Corrected Removed; replaced with credible source or citation
Bruce-124
H 		2 Mar 1316 Lady Marjorie Bruce uncertain 1296 certain Dundonald, Kyle, Ayrshire, Scotland certain Oct 1317 certain Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Wright-7062
Q291049 Marjorie Bruce (Scottish princess (c. 1296 – 1316/17)) 1297 Dundonald United Kingdom 2 Mar 1316 Paisley United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Zimmerman-2446 21.04.2017 07:31:01 Corrected minor correction made to Wikidata
MacDougall-155
H 		1302 Mary de Ergadia MacDougall Countess of Strathearn (MacDougall) aka Abernethy uncertain 1234 uncertain Argyll, Scotland uncertain 10 Oct 1303 uncertain Dunblane, Stirlingshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q21862913 Maria de Ergadia (fourteenth-century Scottish noblewoman) 1302 London United Kingdom female
Huntingdon-28
H 		1130 Maud Queen Maud of Scotland, Maud of Northumberland of Scotland (Huntingdon) aka de Senlis uncertain 1074 certain Huntingdonshire, England uncertain 1131 certain Scone, Perthshire, Scotland Female Wright-7062

WikiTree-65

Lee-759

Fields-574
Q2327302 Maud, Countess of Huntingdon (Queen consort of Scotland) 1074 1130 Kingdom of Scotland Kingdom of Scotland female
Balfour-88
H 		1500 Sir Michael Balfour Ist of Burleigh (Balfour) Kt uncertain 1442 certain Burleigh, Kinross-shire, Scotland after 1496 uncertain Balfour, Fife, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75330180 Michael Balfour (Peerage person ID=67614) 1422 1500 male
Menteith-116
H 		12 Aug 1332 Murdoch Fourth Earl of Menteith (Menteith) uncertain 1274 1333 Male WikiTree-65
Q6933197 Muireadhach III, Earl of Menteith (Scottish nobleman) 12cen 12 Aug 1332 male
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Campbell-2508
H 		1316 Sir Neil Neil Mac Cailein Mór Nicol Campbell of Lochow (Campbell) uncertain 1258 Lochow, Argyleshire, Scotland 1315 Lochow, Argyleshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q16202302 Niall mac Cailein (Nobleman in the Scottish war of Independence) 12cen 1316 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Reid-2564 14.09.2018 07:29:44 Corrected Marriage ended on date of death!
Hepburn-14
H 		1483 Sir Patrick Hepburn First Lord Hailes (Hepburn) uncertain 1412 certain Hailes Castle, Midlothian, Scotland after 6 Dec 1482 certain Hailes Castle, Haddingtonshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q7146715 Patrick Hepburn, 1st Lord Hailes (British politician) East Lothian United Kingdom 1483 male
St Clair-284
H 		1269 Robert 5th Baron Roslin Sinclair (St Clair) 1190 Saint-Clair, Normandy, France after Apr 1248 Roslin Castle, Midlothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75532189 Robert de Saint-Clair ((1190-1269)) 1269 male
De Lawedre-42
H 		Jan 1508 Sir Robert de Lawedre of Bass uncertain 1444 certain Haddingtonshire, Scotland before Feb 1508 certain Tyninghame, Haddingtonshire, Scotland. Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Q7346734 Robert Lauder of The Bass (Scottish politician and noble) 14cen East Lothian United Kingdom Jan 1508 male
Brus-39
H 		1194 Sir Robert le Meschin, the Cadet de Brus IInd of Annandale (Brus) aka Bruce uncertain 1120 Durham, England uncertain 1189 Annandale, Dumfries-Shire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q2535512 Robert de Brus, 2nd Lord of Annandale (12th-century Norman noble) 1120s 1194 male
Keith-393
H 		11 Aug 1332 Sir Robert Marischal of Scotland Keith uncertain 1274 uncertain Scotland uncertain 1343 certain Dupplin, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q7345780 Robert II Keith, Marischal of Scotland (Scottish noble) 11 Aug 1332 Battle of Dupplin Moor Kingdom of Scotland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 16.06.2021 04:34:33 Not corrected Keith's d.o.d. is disputed among historians. It is known that he did not die in 1332. These discrepancies are addressed in the bio.
Lohbeck-3 04.07.2021 00:21:57 Not corrected Through extensive research, Wikidata appears incorrect.
Keith-1090
H 		1346 Robert Marischal of Scotland Keith uncertain 1316 uncertain Scotland after 1336 certain Durham, England Male WikiTree-65
Q7345770 Robert III Keith (Scottish nobleman and hereditary Great Marischal of Scotland) 1346 male
Boyd-546
H 		1474 Thomas Boyd First Earl of Arran (Boyd) before 1453 Kilmarnock, Renfrewshire, Scotland uncertain 1473 Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium Male WikiTree-65

Hamilton-4105
Q4090351 Thomas Boyd, Earl of Arran (Scottish nobleman) 1474 male
Brus-98
H 		9 Feb 1307 Thomas de Brus (Brus) aka Bruce, Brewes 1284 Carrick, Scotland 17 Feb 1307 Carlisle, Cumberland, England Male WikiTree-65
Q7239560 Thomas de Brus (brother of Robert I of Scotland) 1284 9 Feb 1307 9 Feb 1307 male
Stewart-295
H 		1246 Walter IIIrd High Steward of Scotland (Stewart) aka of Dundonald, uncertain 1170 Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland uncertain 1241 Dundonald, Ayrshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Stuart-531
Q958548 Walter Stewart, 3rd High Steward of Scotland (3rd hereditary High Steward of Scotland and Justiciar of Scotia (1198-1246)) 1198 1246 male
FitzAlan-573
H 		1178 Walter Ist High Steward of Scotland (FitzAlan) uncertain 1105 Bretagne, France 2 Feb 1177 Paisley Abbey, Renfrewshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Fields-574

Stuart-531
Q593455 Walter fitz Alan (Anglo-Norman nobleman) 1110 1178 Melrose Abbey United Kingdom male
Comyn-46
H 		Dec 1258 Walter Lord of Badenoch, 4th Earl of Menteith Comyn 1190 Buchan, Aberdeenshire, , Scotland uncertain Nov 1258 Perth, Perthshire, , Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q2543918 Walter Comyn, Lord of Badenoch (Scottish noble (died 1258)) 12000101 Dec 1258 male
Douglas-630
H 		1427 Sir William Douglas Ist of Drumlanrig (Douglas) 1373 Dumfries-shire, Scotland uncertain 1421 certain Lorraine, France Male WikiTree-65
Q8007949 William Douglas (Scottish nobleman and soldier, died 1427) 1427 male
Douglas-388
H 		1391 Sir William Douglas Lord of Nithsdale (Douglas) uncertain 1370 certain Nithsdale, Dumfries-shire, Scotland certain 1392 certain Dumfries-shire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q8007952 William Douglas of Nithsdale (Scottish knight and Northern Crusader) 1364 1391 male
Douglas-653
H 		22 Feb 1452 William Douglas VIIIth Earl of Douglas (Douglas) uncertain 1425 Douglas Castle, Douglas, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 22 Feb 1450 Stirling Castle, Stirling, Stirlingshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q920299 William Douglas, 8th Earl of Douglas (Scottish nobleman) 1425 22 Feb 1452 Stirling Castle United Kingdom male
Dunkeld-65
H 		1147 William FitzDuncan Moray (Dunkeld) aka Earl of Moray, Lord of Egremont uncertain 1090 uncertain Scotland uncertain 1151 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Athey-67
Q1778144 William fitz Duncan (Son of king Donnchad II of Scotland) 1090 1147 male
De la Haye-59
H 		1437 Sir William Hay First Lord Hay and Eighth Baron Erroll (de la Haye) uncertain 1374 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland 1436 Turriff, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Shelton-1487
Q19325866 Sir William de la Haye, 1st Lord Hay (Scottish nobleman, died 1437) 1437 male
Keith-1273
H 		1483 Sir William Keith Second Earl Marischal (Keith) uncertain 1426 Stonehaven, Kincardineshire, Scotland 10 Dec 1482 Dunnottar Castle, Kincardineshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q18672869 William Keith, 1st Earl Marischal (Scottish nobleman (b. after 1425, d. 1483)) 14cen 1483 male
Douglas-112
H 		1298 Sir William Le Hardi Douglas Vth of Doublas (Douglas) Knt aka de Douglas before 1255 Douglas Castle, Lanarkshire, Scotland before 24 Jan 1299 certain Tower of London, London, Middlesex, England Male WikiTree-65
Q1123011 William the Hardy, Lord of Douglas (Scottish nobleman and warlord) 1243 Scotland United Kingdom 1298 London United Kingdom male
Murray-575
H 		15 Jun 1452 Sir William Murray VIIIth of Tullibardine (Murray) certain 1432 Tullibardine Castle, Blackford, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1459 Tullibardine Castle, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q75267242 Sir William Murray of Tullibardine (Peerage person ID=24076) 1432 15 Jun 1452 male
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
St Clair-21
H 		1299 Sir William Sinclair Ist of Rosslyn (St Clair) uncertain 1230 uncertain 1297 Tower of London, London, England Male WikiTree-65
Q18813409 William Sinclair (Scottish baron (died 1299x1303)) 12cen 1299 male
Sutherland-1243
H 		1370 William Sutherland Fifth Earl of Sutherland (Sutherland) uncertain 1311 1371 Sutherland, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q7620356 William de Moravia, 5th Earl of Sutherland (Scottish chief of Clan Sutherland) 13cen 1370 male