Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Gordon-5051
H
19 Jul 1333 Sir Adam Gordon VIIIth of Gordon (Gordon) uncertain 1290 certain Scotland uncertain 1351 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75778397 Sir Adam Gordon of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=329376) 19 Jul 1333 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:25:21 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Macdonald-1568
H
7 May 1449 Alexander Alasdair MacDomhnaill, Lord of the Isles MacDonald Xth Earl of Ross (Macdonald) aka of Islay 1398 Scotland certain 8 May 1449 certain Dingwall, Ross-shire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q2833745 Alexander of Islay, Earl of Ross (Scottish nobleman and Lord of the Isles) 1390 7 May 1449 Dingwall United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 22.11.2020 05:45:50 False suggestion no source on wikitree, difference of 1 day
Bonkyl-2
H
22 Jul 1298 Sir Alexander de Bonkyl (Bonkyl) uncertain uncertain Scotland before 27 Apr 1300 uncertain Scotland Male Hutson-439

Stewart-6071

WikiTree-65
Q61483840 Alexander of Bonkyl (Peerage person ID=4864) 1237 22 Jul 1298 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:21:13 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Seton-25
H
7 Jan 1661 Sir Alexander Montgomerie Sixth Earl of Eglinton (Seton) 1588 Eglinton, Ayrshire, Scotland certain 14 Jan 1661 Eglinton, Ayrshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q16146131 Alexander Montgomerie, 6th Earl of Eglinton (Scottish nobleman) 1588 7 Jan 1661 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 22.11.2020 20:42:36 False suggestion wikidata has different sources
Stewart-3662
H
Jan 1581 Sir Alexander Stewart Vth of Garlies (Stewart) 19 Sep 1507 Garlieston, Wigtownshire, Scotland after 4 Feb 1593 Garlieston, Wigtownshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Wiegand-310
Q75715043 Sir Alexander Stewart, 5th of Garlies (Peerage person ID=299348) Jan 1581 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:33:29 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Douglas-402
H
1238 Sir Archibald Douglas IInd of Douglas (Douglas) before 1175 Hermiston, Edinburghshire, Scotland uncertain 1240 Douglas, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q4170054 Archibald I, Lord of Douglas (Scottish knight) 1198 1238 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 27.06.2021 00:53:58 False suggestion both dates are unsourced, 1198 is date mentioned in charter, not birth
Mure-8
H
1289 Sir Archibald Mure IInd of Rowallan (Mure) uncertain 1231 Rowallan Castle, Kilmarnock, Ayrshire, Scotland 30 Mar 1296 Berwickshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75242567 Sir Archibald Mure of Rowallan (Peerage person ID=4661) 1231 1289 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:23:30 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Hay-45
H
1460 Sir David Hay First Lord Yester (Hay) certain 1394 Lochowart Castle, Gorebridge, Midlothian, Scotland uncertain 1466 uncertain Yester Castle, Gifford, East Lothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75388481 Sir David Hay of Lochorwart and Yester (Peerage person ID=108223) 1394 1460 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 19:20:10 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Lennox-370
H
1365 Donald Lennox aka VI Earl of Lennox uncertain uncertain Scotland before 1364 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Gordon-7317
Q5290248 Domhnall, Earl of Lennox (Scottish noble) 13cen 1365 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 22.10.2021 23:36:23 False suggestion 1364 or before d.o.d. is source confirmed
Munro-457
H
1192 Donald Munro IIIrd Baron and Vth of Foulis (Munro) before 1164 Ross-shire, Scotland uncertain 1195 Foulis, Ross-shire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Straiton-4
Q75747238 Donald Munro (Peerage person ID=313689) 1192 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:23:10 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Dunkeld-76
H
1100 Edmund Edmund I King of Scots (Dunkeld) 1070 Scotland after 1097 certain Montacute, Somerset, England Male Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q729517 Edmund of Scotland (Scottish prince) 11cen 1100 Montacute United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 22.11.2020 21:31:11 False suggestion no sources, death date is disputed
Arnot-3
H
1527 Elizabeth Arnot before 1450 certain Balbarton, Fifeshire, Scotland before 31 Jan 1528 uncertain Hiltoun, Stirlingshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75615006 Elizabeth Arnot (Peerage person ID=246257) 1527 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:55:59 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Burgh-45
H
27 Oct 1327 Elizabeth Queen Consort of Scotland (Burgh) aka de Brus uncertain 1290 uncertain Scotland certain 26 Oct 1327 certain Cullen, Banffshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q262059 Elizabeth de Burgh (Irish noblewoman and Queen consort of Scotland (c.1284–1327)) 1284 Dunfermline United Kingdom 27 Oct 1327 Cullen United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McCallum-662 21.04.2018 19:16:54 Comment Left a comment on the profile.
Noland-165 22.11.2018 18:06:13 False suggestion looked up death date in Richardson's RA, which has the 26th. I don't have access to the source cited by Wikipedia to confirm date was correctly copied from source (ODNB).
Mac Domangairt-2
H
560 Gabrán The Treacherous, King of Dál Riata, Gabhran Conran mac Domangairt aka of Scotland uncertain 507 Kingdom of Dál Riata, Scotland uncertain 558 Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q375287 Gabrán mac Domangairt (King of Dál Riata in the mid-6th century) 5cen 560 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 26.03.2020 13:36:02 False suggestion
Hay-298
H
1573 Sir George Hay Seventh Earl of Erroll (Hay) 1508 Perthshire, Scotland certain 30 Jan 1574 Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Thomas-10705
Q983215 George Hay, 7th Earl of Erroll (Scottish Earl (1508-1573)) 1508 Errol United Kingdom 1573 Perth United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 29.03.2020 03:07:30 False suggestion
Angus-1355
H
1206 Gille Críst Gilchrist of Angus (Angus) uncertain 1142 Angus, Forfarshire, Scotland certain 1204 Angus, Scotland Male Lee-759

WikiTree-65

Crawford-15512
Q5561989 Gille Críst, Earl of Angus (ruled until 1206 as Mormaer of Angus) 12cen Angus United Kingdom 1206 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Crawford-15512 06.02.2021 05:20:45 False suggestion Wikidata gives no source
Montgomery-643
H
5 Aug 1388 Hugh Montgomery uncertain 1360 certain Eaglesham, Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 19 Aug 1388 certain Otterburne, Northumberland, England Male WikiTree-65
Q75635524 Hugh Montgomery (Peerage person ID=261146) 5 Aug 1388 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 19:18:20 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Stewart-4030
H
1448 Sir James Stewart Black Knight of Lorn (Stewart) uncertain 1395 Innermeath, Argyllshire, Scotland after 17 Aug 1451 certain North Sea Male WikiTree-36

WikiTree-65
Q6143629 James Stewart, the Black Knight of Lorn (Scottish noble) 1395 1448 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Snow-2128 22.02.2018 20:10:06 False suggestion Wikidata date is wrong.
Noland-165 25.02.2019 16:00:02 False suggestion no source for 1395 birth; added Research Notes section about the dates (birth & death)
Douglas-407
H
1451 Janet Douglas uncertain 1430 certain Douglas Castle, Douglas, Lanarkshire, Scotland before 2 Oct 1480 uncertain Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75388192 Lady Janet Douglas (Peerage person ID=108021) 1430 1451 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:52:28 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Macdonald-91
H
1386 John Macdonald Lord of the Isles (Macdonald) uncertain 1318 Finlaggan Castle, Isle of Islay, Argyll, Scotland 1387 Ardtornish Castle, Morvern, Argyll, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Straiton-4

Quigley-173
Q3024016 John of Islay (Scottish Lord of the Isles (1336–1386) and chief of Clan Donald) 1318 Scotland United Kingdom 1386 Ardtornish Castle United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 26.03.2020 14:40:37 False suggestion
Madison-125 26.03.2020 14:42:50 Comment
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Lindsay-2400
H
1447 John of Crambeth Lindsay uncertain 1400 Dowhill Scotland uncertain 1455 Dowhill Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q76055216 John Lindsay, 2nd of Dowhill (Peerage person ID=498860) 1400 1447 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 19:21:56 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Ogilvy-8
H
Jun 1489 Sir John Ogilvy of Lintrathen (Ogilvy) 1402 Lintrathen, Forfarshire, Scotland uncertain 1484 Lintrathen, Forfarshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Wright-7062
Q75240491 Sir John Ogilvy of Lintrathen (Peerage person ID=2635) 1402 Jun 1489 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 19:22:31 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Comyn-32
H
1275 Sir John The Red Comyn I Comyn uncertain 1215 uncertain Scotland before 18 Jul 1278 certain Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q16850504 John I Comyn, Lord of Badenoch (Lord of Badenoch in Scotland) 1215 1275 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-1 03.06.2023 05:47:53 False suggestion The 1278 date is cited by Douglas Richardson and t
Lennox-368
H
1303 Malcolm IV Earl of Lennox (Lennox) before 1248 Scotland after 24 May 1297 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q6753628 Maol Choluim I, Earl of Lennox (Scottish noble) 13cen 1303 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 27.10.2021 04:27:47 False suggestion after 24 May 1297 is certain. 1303 is only probab
Dunkeld-90
H
1045 Maldred Lord of Allerdale and Carlisle of Scotland (Dunkeld) uncertain 1003 certain Carlisle, Cumberland, Scotland after 1051 uncertain Winlaton, Durham, England Male WikiTree-65

Lee-759
Q18123097 Maldred (Peerage person ID=106641) 1045 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:22:46 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Stewart-3215
H
26 Jul 1524 Mariote Marjory Stewart aka Stuart uncertain 1490 Of, Balveny, Fifeshire, Scotland uncertain 26 Jul 1529 Island of Lochtay, Perthshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75451712 Lady Marjory Stewart (Peerage person ID=150490) 1490 26 Jul 1524 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 23.11.2020 07:03:38 False suggestion date not sourced
Graham-13967
H
Dec 1720 Mary Allardice (Graham) before 12 Dec 1641 certain Perthshire, Scotland certain Nov 1720 certain Kincardineshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75240924 Mary Graham (Peerage person ID=3053) Dec 1720 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-17201 29.10.2022 21:25:39 False suggestion The Scots Peerage (Paul, p.142) gives the death as
Dunkeld-43
H
Jun 1116 Mary Countess of Boulogne and Lens (Dunkeld) uncertain uncertain Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland certain 31 May 1115 certain Bermondsey, Surrey, England Female WikiTree-65
Q2757982 Mary of Scotland, Countess of Boulogne (Countess consort of Boulogne) 5 May 1082 Jun 1116 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 30.10.2021 18:16:32 False suggestion
Hay-1186
H
1332 Nicholas de la Hay (Hay) aka de la Haya uncertain 1288 uncertain Slains Castle, Buchan, Aberdeenshire, Scotland before 1333 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75662155 Nicholas de la Haye, younger of Erroll (Peerage person ID=278489) 1292 1332 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:24:53 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Arbuthnot-9
H
16 Mar 1633 Sir Robert 17th of Arbuthnott Arbuthnot of Arrat (Arbuthnot) 1595 Arbuthnott, Kincardineshire, Scotland 15 Mar 1633 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q43915812 Sir Robert Arbuthnott of that Ilk (person associated with the witch trials in Scotland) 1595 16 Mar 1633 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 13.09.2023 19:24:58 False suggestion Not sourced
Bruce-517
H
Apr 1295 Sir Robert Bruce the Competitor Fifth Lord of Annandale (Bruce) aka de Brus 1210 certain Annandale, Dumfriesshire, Scotland certain 31 Mar 1295 certain Lochmaben Castle, Dumfriesshire, Scotland Male Wright-7062

WikiTree-65
Q2526281 Robert de Brus, 5th Lord of Annandale (Regent of Scotland and competitor for the Scottish throne) 1210 Apr 1295 Lochmaben United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-10705 13.01.2018 16:38:49 Corrected Updated to reflect Wikipedia source
Thomas-10705 01.03.2018 17:16:23 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Sempill-18
H
1573 Sir Robert Great Lord Sempill Sempill Third Lord Sempill (Sempill) before 17 Jul 1501 certain Eliotstoun, Renfrewshire, Scotland before 17 Jan 1576 certain Eliotstoun, Renfrewshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q7349682 Robert Sempill, 3rd Lord Sempill (Scottish lord of Parliament) 1573 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lenover-1 16.10.2020 22:43:35 False suggestion Death dates are are a range of 5-6 years
Erskine-88
H
1494 Sir Thomas Erskine Second Lord Erskine (Erskine) 1425 Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland before 1493 Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q7789378 Thomas Erskine, 2nd Lord Erskine (Scottish peer) 15cen 1494 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:50:56 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Drummond-54
H
1455 Sir Walter Drummond of Cargill and Stobhall (Drummond) uncertain 1380 certain Stobhill, Perth, Scotland uncertain 1445 uncertain Midlothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75275013 Sir Walter Drummond of Cargill and Stobhall (Peerage person ID=30589) 1380 1455 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 19:19:10 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Borthwick-128
H
1449 Sir William Borthwick IInd of Borthwick (Borthwick) Knt. after 1390 certain Scotland before 1450 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Q27229724 Sir William Borthwick of that ilk (Scottish landowner and administrator) 1385 1449 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 10.04.2022 23:11:23 False suggestion
Hay-472
H
29 Aug 1392 Sir William Hay of Locherworth (Hay) aka de Hay before 1325 Lochorwart Castle, Gorebridge, Midlothian, Scotland certain 1380 uncertain Lochorwart Castle, Gorebridge, Midlothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75964925 Sir William Haya of Lochorwart (Peerage person ID=434840) 1330 29 Aug 1392 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:28:40 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Keith-313
H
1444 Sir William Keith Earl of Marischal (Keith) 1389 Dunottar, Kincardineshire, Scotland before 16 Mar 1464 uncertain Dunottar Castle, Stonehaven, Kincardineshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q73756835 William Keith (Peerage person ID=109265) 13cen 1444 Oct 1444 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 19:19:54 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Oliphant-731
H
1329 Sir William of Aberdalgie Oliphant Knt. uncertain 1270 certain 5 Feb 1330 certain Aberdalgie, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Stevens-17832
Q8016335 William Oliphant, Lord of Aberdalgie (Scottish magnate and military leader) 1329 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 30.07.2020 00:57:16 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced, this profile is sourced
Stirling-670
H
1517 William of Cadder Stirling uncertain 1450 Cadder, Lanarkshire, Scotland uncertain 1516 Cadder, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Straiton-4
Q76178125 William Stirling, 11th of Cadder and 2nd of Lettyr (Peerage person ID=584443) 1517 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:55:46 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Sinclair-144
H
1484 William Sinclair Third Earl of Orkney First Earl of Caithness (Sinclair) uncertain 1404 certain Roslin, Edinburghshire, Scotland before Mar 1480 certain Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q3568958 William Sinclair, 1st Earl of Caithness (Scottish nobleman, last Jarl of Orkney; Lord Chancellor of Scotland) 1410 1484 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 22.11.2020 21:39:54 False suggestion dates are uncertain and not sourced
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Moravia-9
H
1307 William Sutherland Second Earl of Sutherland (Moravia) after 1235 Sutherland, Scotland certain 1306 Sutherland, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q63079993 William Sutherland, 2nd Earl of Sutherland (Peerage person ID=710786) 12cen 1307 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:24:30 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable