Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Warning 563: Wikidata - Possible duplicate by father Help (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Moray-48
H
Compare Duff MacEth of Moray (Moray) Wikitree Father uncertain 1078 Methil, Fifeshire, Scotland 1128 Male Bairfield-1
Dunkeld-80
H
Æthelred Aedh Abbot of Dunkeld (Dunkeld) aka Earl of Fife Wikidata Father after 1070 Morayshire, Scotland uncertain 1093 certain St Andrews (Kikrimont), Fife, Scotland Male Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q5561994 Gille Míchéil, Earl of Fife (Scottish noble) 11000101 1130s male
Q4444623 Ethelred of Scotland (Scottish royal) 10cen Scotland United Kingdom 11cen Scotland United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 18.01.2023 20:45:30 False suggestion
Angus-1355
H
Compare Gille Críst Gilchrist of Angus (Angus) Wikitree Father uncertain 1142 Angus, Forfarshire, Scotland certain 1204 Angus, Scotland Male Lee-759

WikiTree-65

Crawford-15512
Angus-22
H
Gillbride Earl of Angus of Angus (Angus) Wikidata Father 1118 Forfarshire, Scotland 1187 Forfarshire, Scotland Male Crawford-15512

WikiTree-65

Wright-7062
Q16239683 Gille Brigte, Earl of Angus (Mormaer of Angus) 11cen Angus United Kingdom 1187 male
Q75244887 Magnus, Jarl of Orkney (Peerage person ID=6591) 1180 1239 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Crawford-15512 06.02.2021 05:18:50 False suggestion Different people
Keith-474
H
Compare Sir John Keith Wikitree Father uncertain 1340 18 Mar 1375 Male WikiTree-65

Lockwood-1016
Keith-260
H
Sir William Keith Great Marischal of Scotland (Keith) Wikidata Father after 1306 uncertain Scotland after 2 May 1407 Dunnotter, Kincardineshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q18672868 William Keith (Scottish marischal (d. in or after 1407)) 1315 1407 male
Q75778451 Elizabeth Keith (Peerage person ID=329401) 1361 1436 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 17.10.2021 07:29:00 False suggestion
Stewart-1555
H
Compare Sir John Stewart of Balveny First Earl of Atholl (Stewart) Wikitree Father uncertain 1440 uncertain Mortlach, Banffshire, Scotland certain 15 Sep 1512 certain Laighwood, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Stewart-1604
H
John Stewart Second Earl of Atholl (Stewart) Wikidata Father after 1475 uncertain Balveny, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1521 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Douglass-990

Felch-7
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q1701828 John Stewart, 2nd Earl of Atholl (Scottish peer and soldier) 1475 1521 male
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:57:20 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately
Stewart-1604
H
Compare John Stewart Second Earl of Atholl (Stewart) Wikitree Father after 1475 uncertain Balveny, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1521 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Douglass-990

Felch-7
Stewart-1555
H
Sir John Stewart of Balveny First Earl of Atholl (Stewart) Wikidata Father uncertain 1440 uncertain Mortlach, Banffshire, Scotland certain 15 Sep 1512 certain Laighwood, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q1240207 John Stewart, 1st Earl of Atholl (Scottish diplomat; eldest son of Joan Beaufort and Sir James Stewart, the Black Knight of Lorn) 1440 15 Sep 1512 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:57:34 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately
Stewart-1604
H
Compare John Stewart Second Earl of Atholl (Stewart) Wikitree Father after 1475 uncertain Balveny, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1521 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Douglass-990

Felch-7
Stewart-1555
H
Sir John Stewart of Balveny First Earl of Atholl (Stewart) Wikidata Father uncertain 1440 uncertain Mortlach, Banffshire, Scotland certain 15 Sep 1512 certain Laighwood, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q1240207 John Stewart, 1st Earl of Atholl (Scottish diplomat; eldest son of Joan Beaufort and Sir James Stewart, the Black Knight of Lorn) 1440 15 Sep 1512 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:57:34 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately
Gilbertsson-6
H
Compare Magnus Gilbertsson aka of Caithness and Orkney Wikitree Father 1273 Male Gordon-7317

WikiTree-65

Crawford-15512
Magnusson-1153
H
Magnus Magnusson Wikidata Father uncertain 1207 Orkney, Scotland 1284 Orkney, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Crawford-15512
Q75532166 John, Jarl of Orkney (Peerage person ID=198312) 1259 1311 male
Q75532165 Malcolm, Jarl of Orkney (Peerage person ID=198311) 1207 1284 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Crawford-15512 06.02.2021 04:35:46 False suggestion These are two different people
Gilbertsson-6
H
Compare Magnus Gilbertsson aka of Caithness and Orkney Wikitree Father 1273 Male Gordon-7317

WikiTree-65

Crawford-15512
Gilchristsson-1
H
Magnus Gilchristsson aka of Orkney and Caithness Wikidata Father uncertain 1180 Forfar, Angus, Scotland 1239 uncertain Orkney, Scotland Male Crawford-15512

WikiTree-65
Q75244887 Magnus, Jarl of Orkney (Peerage person ID=6591) 1180 1239 male
Q75532165 Malcolm, Jarl of Orkney (Peerage person ID=198311) 1207 1284 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Crawford-15512 06.02.2021 04:35:46 False suggestion These are two different people
Bruce-517
H
Compare Sir Robert Bruce the Competitor Fifth Lord of Annandale (Bruce) aka de Brus Wikitree Father 1210 certain Annandale, Dumfriesshire, Scotland certain 31 Mar 1295 certain Lochmaben Castle, Dumfriesshire, Scotland Male Wright-7062

WikiTree-65
Bruce-129
H
Robert Earl of Carrick and Lord of Annandale Bruce First King of Scots (Bruce) aka de Brus The Bruce Wikidata Father certain 11 Jul 1274 uncertain Writtle, Essex, England certain 7 Jun 1329 certain Cardross, Dunbartonshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75238197 Isabel de Bruce (Peerage person ID=857) female
Q187312 Robert I of Scotland (King of Scotland (r. 1306–1329)) 11 Jul 1274 1274 Turnberry Castle United Kingdom 7 Jun 1329 1329 Cardross United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 18.08.2020 11:27:07 False suggestion Different people
Borthwick-605
H
Compare Sir William Borthwick First Lord Borthwick (Borthwick) Knt. Wikitree Father uncertain 1413 certain Scotland certain Oct 1483 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Sutherland-Fisher-1

Simpkinson-1
Borthwick-167
H
Sir William Borthwick Second Lord Borthwick (Borthwick) Wikidata Father uncertain 1445 certain Scotland certain 20 May 1503 certain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Q16197519 William Borthwick, 3rd Lord Borthwick (Scottish nobleman, ambassador and Master of the King's Household) 20 May 1503 male
Q8005726 William Borthwick, 2nd Lord Borthwick (Scottish diplomat) 1428 May 1503 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 03.06.2022 05:20:36 False suggestion Not duplicated
Lohbeck-3 03.06.2022 05:21:12 Comment
Borthwick-167
H
Compare Sir William Borthwick Second Lord Borthwick (Borthwick) Wikitree Father uncertain 1445 certain Scotland certain 20 May 1503 certain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Borthwick-135
H
Sir William Borthwick Third Lord Borthwick (Borthwick) Knt. Wikidata Father uncertain 1463 uncertain Scotland. certain 28 May 1543 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Q75444265 Catherine Borthwick (Peerage person ID=145322) 1482 female
Q8005728 William Borthwick, 4th Lord Borthwick (Scottish nobleman) 1490 1543 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lauder-Frost-1 15.02.2024 09:12:37 False suggestion
Borthwick-135
H
Compare Sir William Borthwick Third Lord Borthwick (Borthwick) Knt. Wikitree Father uncertain 1463 uncertain Scotland. certain 28 May 1543 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Borthwick-167
H
Sir William Borthwick Second Lord Borthwick (Borthwick) Wikidata Father uncertain 1445 certain Scotland certain 20 May 1503 certain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Q8005726 William Borthwick, 2nd Lord Borthwick (Scottish diplomat) 1428 May 1503 male
Q50824552 Catherine Borthwick (Peerage person ID=145414) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lauder-Frost-1 15.02.2024 09:12:36 False suggestion
Borthwick-135
H
Compare Sir William Borthwick Third Lord Borthwick (Borthwick) Knt. Wikitree Father uncertain 1463 uncertain Scotland. certain 28 May 1543 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Borthwick-167
H
Sir William Borthwick Second Lord Borthwick (Borthwick) Wikidata Father uncertain 1445 certain Scotland certain 20 May 1503 certain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Lauder-Frost-1
Q16197519 William Borthwick, 3rd Lord Borthwick (Scottish nobleman, ambassador and Master of the King's Household) 20 May 1503 male
Q50824552 Catherine Borthwick (Peerage person ID=145414) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lauder-Frost-1 15.02.2024 09:12:36 False suggestion
Dunkeld-65
H
Compare William FitzDuncan Moray (Dunkeld) aka Earl of Moray, Lord of Egremont Wikitree Father uncertain 1090 uncertain Scotland uncertain 1151 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Athey-67
MacWilliam-9
H
William the boy of Egremont de Egremont (MacWilliam) Wikidata Father after 1138 Egremont, Cumberland, England after 1163 Male Thompson-14289
Q3036054 Donald MacWilliam (Claimant to the Scottish throne) 11cen 1187 31 Jul 1187 male
Q75387801 William MacWilliam, Lord of Egremont (Peerage person ID=107706) 1155 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 01.12.2020 07:02:20 False suggestion wikidata is incorrect -has 2 fathers for Q3036054