Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Hancock-8902
H
24 Dec 1806 Albany Hancock certain 26 Dec 1806 Newcastle upon Tyne, Northumberland, England certain 1873 Newcastle upon Tyne, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom Male Humphrey-6461
Q2830808 Albany Hancock (English naturalist, biologist and supporter of Charles Darwin (1806-1873)) 24 Dec 1806 Newcastle upon Tyne United Kingdom 1873 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Humphrey-6461 13.09.2020 23:51:59 False suggestion Christening source supports date on wikitree profile.
Gordon-5394
H
1476 Sir Alexander Gordon of Lochinvar (Gordon) before 1478 Lochinvar, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Flodden, Branxton, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Q75389837 Sir Alexander Gordon of Kenmure and Lochinvar, younger (Peerage person ID=109565) 1476 9 Sep 1513 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 23:00:13 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Stewart-3703
H
1481 Sir Alexander Stewart IVth of Garlies (Stewart) before 20 May 1472 certain Garlieston, Wigtownshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Flodden Field, Kirknewton, Branxton, Northumberland, England Male Stuart-531
Q75715041 Sir Alexander Stewart, 4th of Garlies (Peerage person ID=299347) 1481 9 Sep 1513 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:24:40 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Maxwell-9774
H
1855 Annette Mary Maud Cassel (Maxwell) certain 13 May 1854 certain Tynemouth, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom certain 16 Jul 1881 certain Kensington, London, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q75947945 Annette Maxwell ((1855-1881)) 1855 1881 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-2838 16.07.2022 13:32:25 False suggestion
Neville-1617
H
20 Nov 1875 Auber Octavius Neville 20 Oct 1875 Ford, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom certain 18 Apr 1954 Perth, Western Australia, Australia Male Andrewartha-50
Q758440 A. O. Neville (Australian public servant (1875-1954)) 20 Nov 1875 Northumberland United Kingdom 18 May 1954 Perth Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 15:07:03 False suggestion WikiData is incorrect. Baptism on 16 Nov, so couldn't have been born on 20 Nov
Parke-752
H
12 Nov 1819 Cecilia Anne Ridley (Parke) certain 13 Nov 1819 York, Yorkshire, England 20 Apr 1845 Castle Ward, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q75341949 Cecilia Anne Parke ((1819-1845)) 12 Nov 1819 20 Apr 1845 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Humphrey-6461 11.03.2022 16:53:00 False suggestion Correct date added from newspaper source.
Allhusen-6
H
24 Dec 1840 Christian Wilton Allhusen before 11 May 1841 Newcastle upon Tyne, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom 1924 Male Bates-10490
Q75356684 Christian Wilton Allhusen ((born 1840)) 24 Dec 1840 1924 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bates-10490 04.10.2023 19:40:15 False suggestion Peerage is not a source!
Kennedy-874
H
21 Dec 1471 David Kennedy First Earl of Cassillis (Kennedy) uncertain 1465 Maybole, Ayrshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Flodden Field, Branxton, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Q5235930 David Kennedy, 1st Earl of Cassilis (Scottish nobleman) 21 Dec 1471 9 Sep 1513 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 13.07.2023 22:13:25 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Riddell-1553
H
1698 Edward Horsley Widdrington Riddell uncertain 23 Jun 1766 Swinburn, Northumberland, England. certain 26 Jan 1793 certain Durham, England Male Orphan
Q75486091 Edward Horsley Widdrington ((1698-1762)) 1698 1762 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
haddock-479 01.04.2020 13:16:53 False suggestion Completely different people
haddock-479 27.05.2020 08:09:51 False suggestion Wikidata is a different person
Neville-49
H
1398 Eleanor Percy (Neville) aka le Despencer uncertain 1400 uncertain England before 6 Feb 1473 certain England Female WikiTree-36

Stewart-6071
Q5354354 Eleanor Percy, Countess of Northumberland (English countess) 1398 County Durham United Kingdom 1472 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Chittem-20 17.06.2017 11:45:18 False suggestion Protected project - Manager contacted
Rankin-394
H
6 Nov 1771 Elizabeth Martineau (Rankin) certain 8 Oct 1771 St John, Newcastle upon Tyne, Northumberland, England certain 26 Aug 1848 certain Edgbaston, Warwickshire, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q75537539 Elizabeth Rankin ((1771-1848)) 6 Nov 1771 26 Aug 1848 1848 Edgbaston United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Metcalf-1784 11.03.2023 01:06:48 False suggestion That was Christening date
Kemble-224
H
1785 Frances Crawford Arkwright (Kemble) 23 Aug 1786 Matlock, Derbyshire, England 10 Mar 1849 Chesterfield, Derbyshire, England, United Kingdom Female France-1307
Q76203244 Frances Crawford Kemble ((1785-1849)) 1785 10 Mar 1849 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 11.03.2020 11:21:56 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Heathcote-126 13.03.2020 20:20:25 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Younghusband-83
H
22 Nov 1816 Frances Younghusband certain 9 Nov 1816 Berwick-upon-Tweed, Northumberland, England certain 5 Feb 1863 Freshford, Somerset, England, United Kingdom Female Bates-10490
Q75788491 Frances Younghusband ((1816-1863)) 22 Nov 1816 4 Feb 1863 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bates-10490 02.12.2023 18:06:47 False suggestion Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced
Vane-226
H
10 May 1618 Sir George Vane Jul 1618 Shipbourne, Kent, England 1676 Long Newton, Durham, England Male Hacker-831
Q75392546 Sir George Vane ((born 1618)) 10 May 1618 1676 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hacker-831 01.09.2021 21:51:53 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Percy-37
H
1156 Henry de Percy (Percy) uncertain 1160 Alnwick, Northumberland, England 1198 Rouen, Seine-Maritime, Haute-Normandie, France Male Dellinger-332
Q18215269 Henry de Percy (English nobleman and landowner) 1156 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 01.01.2024 21:57:21 False suggestion
Percy-40
H
1321 Sir Henry Henry V 3rd Lord Percy, 3rd Lord of the Honor of Skipton de Percy (Percy) uncertain 1320 certain Seamer, Yorkshire, England uncertain 18 May 1368 Warkworth, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Q11802623 Henry de Percy, 3rd Baron Percy (English baron and High Sheriff of Northumberland) 1321 18 May 1368 Alnwick Castle United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 13.05.2020 20:28:46 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Darling-2219
H
1840 Isabella Eleanor Aylmer (Darling) uncertain 1832 Bellshill, Chatton, Northumberland, England certain 27 Dec 1908 certain South Stoneham, Hampshire, England Female Orphan
Q61699244 Isabella Eleanor Aylmer (British novelist and travel writer) 1840 1840 1840 1840 Bellshill United Kingdom 27 Dec 1908 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Humphrey-6461 02.06.2023 10:11:49 False suggestion She was 9 in 1841 - wikidata is wrong
Neville-58
H
1337 Sir John 3rd Lord Neville of Raby de Neville (Neville) KG uncertain 1329 uncertain Raby, Durham, England certain 17 Oct 1388 Newcastle Upon Tyne, Northumberland, England Male WikiTree-36

Athey-67
Q6250305 John Neville, 3rd Baron Neville de Raby (English peer and soldier) 1337 17 Oct 1388 Newcastle upon Tyne United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 16.09.2018 14:30:41 False suggestion see comments on WikiTree profile - it seems both are based on his age from the IPM at the time of his father's death (28-30 in 1368), which is apparently incorrect, being incompatible with the dates of his participation in battles/campaigns
Blair-374
H
1435 John Blair of that Ilk (Blair) before 19 Jan 1457 certain Blair, Ayrshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Q75523279 John Blair of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=193078) 1435 1513 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:56:29 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Fenwick-267
H
1618 John Fenwick Esq. uncertain 1620 uncertain Northumberland, England before 17 Dec 1683 uncertain Salem, Province of New Jersey Male Gorby-7

WikiTree-36

Cooke-7654
Q6232953 John Fenwick (Quaker emigrant leader) 1618 1683 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 30.01.2024 10:21:18 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Cooke-7654 09.03.2024 03:02:14 False suggestion Admitted to Gray's Inn 15 Mar 1638/9 so probably born later than 1618
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Dixwell-1
H
1607 Colonel John James Davids Dixwell 21 Mar 1613 certain Ponteland, Northumberland, England 18 Mar 1689 New Haven, Connecticut Male WikiTree-72
Q6229525 John Dixwell (Dixwell, John (c 1607-1689) Regicide) 1607 1689 18 Mar 1689 Thirteen Colonies Kingdom of Great Britain male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
B-404 09.01.2021 15:36:23 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Robson-2642
H
24 Sep 1808 Joseph Philip Robson uncertain 27 Sep 1808 certain Newcastle upon Tyne, Northumberland, England certain 26 Aug 1870 certain Newcastle upon Tyne, Northumberland, England Male Curnick-42
Q6286228 Joseph Philip Robson (poet, song writer and editor) 24 Sep 1808 26 Aug 1870 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Curnick-42 26.10.2020 15:10:04 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced, I've used an actual source
Ogle-73
H
1401 Margaret Margery Bellingham (Ogle) aka Harbottle uncertain 1405 uncertain Northumberland, England after uncertain England Female WikiTree-36
Q75558011 Margaret Ogle (Peerage person ID=211529) 1401 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 10.08.2020 21:54:36 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Neville-349
H
12 Feb 1341 Margaret Percy (Neville) aka de Ros 12 Feb 1339 Raby Castle, Durham, England 13 May 1372 Warkworth Castle, Northumberland, England Female Orphan
Q68109318 Margaret Neville (countess d. 1372) 12 Feb 1341 May 1372 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 15.09.2020 11:34:30 Comment can't tell where WikiTree's date is from - not Richardson's RA NEVILLE 11
Noland-165 15.09.2020 11:42:11 Comment Russian wikidata cites Cawley but I couldn't find that birth date there either; Lewis has the 1339 date with no citation
Cayley-55 15.09.2020 12:53:40 False suggestion Usual Russian nonsense
Fenwick-270
H
1544 Richard Fenwick Esq 1545 Heaton, Northumberland, England uncertain 1626 Male Gorby-7

WikiTree-36
Q105820925 Richard Fenwick (1544) 1544 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 13.02.2024 10:39:26 False suggestion Wikidata has no god source
Umfreville-104
H
1276 Sir Robert 9th Earl of Angus de Umfreville (Umfreville) aka de Umfraville, de Umframvill uncertain 1277 Northumberland, England before 12 Apr 1325 England Male WikiTree-36

Lee-759
Q7351440 Robert de Umfraville, Earl of Angus (Anglo-Norman baron in Northumberland and Earl of Angus) 1276 Mar 1325 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thiessen-117 11.10.2022 20:21:04 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Matthews-5784
H
1809 Rosabella Fiennes-Clinton (Matthews) certain 23 Oct 1808 certain Tynemouth, Northumberland, England certain 8 Dec 1871 St. Giles, London, England Female McCarthy-2108
Q75857332 Rosabella Matthews ((1809-1871)) 1809 8 Dec 1871 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 13.10.2021 12:17:20 False suggestion Wikidata uses incorrect date from the peerage, wikitree date supported by sources
Barclay-2846
H
20 Feb 1853 Thomas Barclay 20 Oct 1839 Bishopwearmouth, Durham, England, United Kingdom 1921 Bromsgrove, Worcestershire, England, United Kingdom Male Gardiner-1534
Q5565726 Thomas Barclay (British economic writer and politician (1853-1941)) 20 Feb 1853 20 Jan 1941 Versailles France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gardiner-1534 17.11.2020 18:44:06 False suggestion Two different Barclays. Not the same person.
Gardiner-1534 24.11.2020 13:51:44 False suggestion Different Barclay
Macdowall-5
H
1450 Thomas Macdowall Younger of Garthland (Macdowall) before 9 Sep 1495 certain Garthland, Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Branxton, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Q75994893 Thomas Macdowall, younger of Garthland (Peerage person ID=455449) 1450 9 Sep 1513 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 23:03:17 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Godwinson-20
H
1026 Tostig Earl of Northumbria Godwinson uncertain 1025 Wessex, England 25 Sep 1066 Stamford Bridge, Northumberland, England Male Cayley-55
Q345420 Tostig Godwinson (Anglo-Saxon Earl) 1026 25 Sep 1066 Stamford Bridge United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 28.08.2021 20:42:57 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Bedlington-16
H
27 Sep 1823 William Bedlington certain 7 Mar 1810 certain Corbridge, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom certain 24 May 1891 certain Mount Eden, Auckland, New Zealand Male Simmonds-1055
Q104286290 William Bedlington (New Zealand land surveyor (1823-1891)) 27 Sep 1823 Ovingham United Kingdom 24 May 1891 Auckland New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Simmonds-1055 29.03.2022 02:29:43 Not corrected My data matches Source information
Simmonds-1055 29.04.2022 03:42:57 Comment Conflicting Birthday Source removed
Simmonds-1055 29.04.2022 03:43:33 Corrected minor correction made to Wikidata
Simmonds-1055 29.04.2022 03:44:44 Corrected
Simmonds-1055 09.05.2022 03:11:30 Not corrected the Subject of my profile is aged older than the subject referredv to in the Wikidata so its my suggestion that somebody has boobed when they added this Data to my Profile
Simmonds-1055 05.08.2022 11:16:53 Not corrected ERROR 555 -My information is Correct -William was 50 y/0 when he Married.Q104286290
Simmonds-1055 06.08.2022 10:00:03 Corrected Error 555 Amended - Incorrect information removed.
Simmonds-1055 22.08.2022 08:51:08 Corrected Wrong Data removed came via GEDCOM IMPORT AND WAS WRONG
Simmonds-1055 14.09.2022 01:52:32 Comment
Simmonds-1055 14.09.2022 01:54:10 Not corrected Bottom information incorrect -due to corrupted Smart Match.
Simmonds-1055 30.11.2022 08:44:47 Comment William Bedingtons Birth is 1810 -he was Aged 50 and Caroline 32
Simmonds-1055 30.11.2022 08:45:17 Comment
Simmonds-1055 02.12.2022 05:50:38 Comment William Bedington, 1810 - 1891 William Bedington was born on month day 1810, in birth place . William was baptized on month day 1837, in baptism place . William married Caroline Elizabeth Bedington (born Mair) on month day 1861, at age 50 in marriage place . Caroline was born on October 15 1828, in Paihia,Auckland,New Zealand. They had 4 children: Blanche Bedlington and 3 other children . William passed away on month day 1891, at age 81 in death place .
Simmonds-1055 02.12.2022 05:53:20 Comment
Simmonds-1055 02.12.2022 05:55:32 Comment Please read commens in Status History- Wikidata has wrong person
Willis-3607 28.12.2022 05:26:12 Not corrected wikidata incorrect - died 24 May 1891 at age 81= b: 1810
Willis-3076 28.12.2022 05:27:57 False suggestion
Livingston-940
H
1460 William Livingston IIIrd of Kilsyth (Livingston) uncertain 1450 certain Balcastle, Stirlingshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Flodden Field, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Q75423073 William Livingston of Kilsyth (Peerage person ID=132343) 1460 9 Sep 1513 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:55:15 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Neville-257
H
1410 William Lord Fauconberg, Earl of Kent Neville KG uncertain 1400 Raby, Durham, England 9 Jan 1463 Alnwick, Northumberland, England Male WikiTree-113
Q2364228 William Neville, Earl of Kent (English nobleman and soldier (c. 1405–1463)) 1410 9 Jan 1463 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 11.10.2020 17:36:32 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source