Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Challant-5
H
1305 Amé Aymon II de Challant (Challant) uncertain 1300 Valle d'Aosta, Italia before 1387 Valle d'Aosta, Italia Male Marchal-178
Q1631516 Aymon of Challant (Italian noble) 1305 Aosta Valley Italy 1387 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 30.11.2022 07:48:06 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Carpano-1
H
24 Nov 1751 Antonio Benedetto Carpano certain 24 Nov 1764 Bioglio, Biella, Piedmont, Italy certain 1815 Turin Male WikiTree-69
Q2590726 Antonio Benedetto Carpano (Italian inventor) 24 Nov 1751 Bioglio Italy 3 Feb 1821 Bioglio Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Burch-2229 11.12.2020 02:13:25 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Trench-284
H
1824 Augusta Le Poer Childers (Trench) aka Priestly uncertain 1823 Gloucestershire, England, United Kingdom 10 Dec 1914 Florence, Italy Female Orphan
Q75301389 Augusta Trench ((died 1914)) 1824 10 Dec 1914 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Groom-187 16.12.2023 05:26:34 False suggestion
Fieschi-3
H
1225 Beatrice Béatrice di Savoie (Fieschi) uncertain 1215 Villa Fieschi, Lavagna, Italy 9 Jul 1283 Savoy, France Female Heinzelmann-5
Q2929437 Beatrice Fieschi ((1225-1283)) 1225 Jul 1283 Château du Bourget France female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID5260156 24.02.2017 18:42:02 False suggestion Old False error
Visconti-133
H
Apr 1425 Bianca Maria Visconti 31 Mar 1425 Castello di Settimo Pavese, Italy 28 Oct 1468 Melegnano, Italy Female Marchal-178
Q1232642 Bianca Maria Visconti (Duchess of Milan from 1450 to 1468) Apr 1425 Bornasco Italy 13 Aug 1447 23 Oct 1468 28 Oct 1468 Cremona Italy female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 20.04.2021 08:23:21 False suggestion Date of birth is correct.
Hauteville-5
H
1054 Bohemond Bohemond I Marco d'Antioch (Hauteville) aka de Hauteville uncertain 1052 San Marco Argentano, Calabria uncertain 3 Mar 1110 Canossa, Italy Male WikiTree-113
Q220806 Bohemond I of Antioch (Prince of Taranto and Prince of Antioch) 1054 San Marco Argentano Italy 3 Mar 1111 Canosa di Puglia Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 23.04.2018 21:18:07 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Gambino-92
H
24 Aug 1902 Carlo Don Carlo Gambino certain 1 Sep 1902 Palermo, Palermo, Sicily, Italy certain 15 Oct 1976 Massapequa, Nassau, New York, United States Male Cascio-10
Q452127 Carlo Gambino (American mobster) 24 Aug 1902 Palermo Italy 15 Oct 1976 Massapequa United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cascio-10 10.02.2023 22:59:22 False suggestion
De Broglie-4
H
28 Nov 1785 Charles Achille Léonce Victor de Broglie certain 29 Nov 1785 Paris, Île-de-France, France 25 Jan 1870 Paris VII, Paris, Seine, France Male Smith-165384
Q338386 Victor de Broglie (French politician (1785-1870)) 28 Nov 1785 Paris France 25 Jan 1870 Paris France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 20.03.2018 08:51:14 False suggestion
Capet-402
H
21 Mar 1226 Charles Charles I King of Sicily Sicilia (Capet) aka Anjou, Napoli, Jerusalem 21 Mar 1227 uncertain Paris, Ile-de-France, France certain 7 Jan 1285 Foggia, Apulia, Italy Male Atkinson-107

WikiTree-113
Q203829 Charles I of Naples (King of Sicily (1226-1285)) 21 Mar 1226 1226 Paris France 7 Jan 1285 1285 Foggia Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 02.07.2017 10:28:25 False suggestion Wikitree is correct
Capet-577
H
1254 Charles Charles II le Boiteux Napoli (Capet) aka Sicilia uncertain 1248 Naples, Napoli, Campania, Italy 5 May 1309 Caranova, Nr Naples, Italy Male Heinzelmann-5

WikiTree-56

WikiTree-113
Q314331 Charles II of Naples (King of Naples from 1284 to 1309) 1254 Naples Italy 5 May 1309 1309 Naples Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 23.04.2018 21:44:43 False suggestion Dates are approximate
O'Donoghue-242
H
8 Sep 1806 Charles James O'Donoghue 25 Sep 1806 Summerhill, Killarney, County Kerry, Ireland 1 May 1833 Florence, Florence, Tuscany, Italy Male Falvey-115
Q75829279 Charles James O'Donoghue, The O'Donoghue of the Glens ((1806-1833)) 8 Sep 1806 1 May 1833 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 08.08.2023 15:13:38 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Smyth-1938
H
3 Jan 1817 Charles Piazzi Smyth certain 3 Jan 1819 certain Naples, Italy certain 21 Feb 1900 certain Sharow, North Yorkshire, England Male Temple-Watts-3

Temple-Watts-2
Q1065789 Charles Piazzi Smyth (British astronomer (1817-1900)) 3 Jan 1817 Naples Italy 21 Feb 1900 Ripon United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Temple-Watts-2 22.06.2021 19:11:39 Comment All FamilySearch and FindAGrave records cite 1819 as the correct birth year as does the 1891 census and his newspaper obituary.
Temple-Watts-2 22.08.2021 04:40:03 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Bonaparte-57
H
8 Jul 1801 Charlotte Zénaïde Julie Bonaparte 6 Jul 1801 Paris, Seine, France 8 Aug 1854 Napoli, Regno delle Due Sicilie Female Rosner-239
Q247564 Zénaïde Bonaparte (French noble (1801-1854)) 8 Jul 1801 Paris France 8 Aug 1854 Naples Italy female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 27.02.2019 14:57:31 False suggestion Correct date per marriage record; birth record is lost
De Pizan-1
H
1363 Christine de Pizan certain 11 Sep 1364 Venice, Italy uncertain 1430 Poissy, Île-de-France, France Female Orphan
Q234816 Christine de Pizan (French poet and author (1364 – c. 1430)) 1363 1363 Venice Italy 1431 1430 1430 1431 Poissy France female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 21.06.2017 20:08:21 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Sicilia-15
H
1310 Elisabetta von Bayern (Sicilia) aka de Sicilia 1309 Palermo, Palermo, Sicily uncertain 21 Mar 1348 Landshut, Niederbayern, Germany Female Atkinson-107
Q2010317 Elisabeth of Sicily, Duchess of Bavaria (Duchess consort of Bavaria) 1310 21 Mar 1349 Landshut Germany female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 21.04.2019 00:16:24 False suggestion all dates and spellings are unproven
Rome-144
H
347 Faustina Empress Rome before 344 Rome, Italy after 366 Italy Female Orphan
Q63533 Faustina (Roman empress, third wife of Constantius II) 347 4cen female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 24.07.2019 00:15:18 False suggestion no sources for either date, both estimates
Gonzaga-141
H
1330 Feltrino Signore di Reggio Emilia Gonzaga uncertain 1293 certain Mantova, Italia certain 28 Dec 1374 certain Padova, Venice, Veneto, Italy, Europe Male Orphan
Q3742345 Feltrino Gonzaga (Italian condottiero) 1330 Mantua Italy 28 Dec 1374 Padua Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 23.08.2022 13:04:09 False suggestion Date is approximate
Rawdon-47
H
9 Dec 1754 Francis 1st Marquess of Hastings Rawdon-Hastings (Rawdon) KG GCB PC 7 Dec 1754 Moira, County Down, Ireland 28 Nov 1826 On board H.M.S. Revenge anchored at Naples Campania, Italy Male Champion-988
Q692434 Francis Rawdon-Hastings, 1st Marquess of Hastings (Governor-General of India (1754-1826)) 9 Dec 1754 Ireland United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland 28 Nov 1826 Naples Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 16.04.2020 17:04:55 False suggestion ODB states 'His parentage is unknown'
Leuchtenberg-6
H
28 Nov 1872 George Nikolaevich Herzog Leuchtenberg aka von Leuchtenberg certain 10 Dec 1872 Rome Italy certain 9 Aug 1929 Bayern Germany Male Rosner-239
Q4257584 Georgy Nikolayevich of Leuchtenberg ((1872-1929)) 28 Nov 1872 Rome Italy 9 Aug 1929 Seeon-Seebruck Germany male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
rassinot-1 03.04.2019 12:51:09 False suggestion Gregorian/Julian calendar ambiguity: Wikidata entry is based on Russian Wikipedia
Este-125
H
2 Apr 1419 Ginevra d'Este (Este) 24 Mar 1419 Ferrara, Italy 12 Oct 1440 Rimini, Italy Female Marchal-178
Q2946984 Ginevra d'Este ((1419-1440)) 2 Apr 1419 Ferrara Italy 21 Oct 1440 Rimini Italy female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 28.04.2021 08:20:26 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Medici-69
H
23 May 1567 Don Giovanni de Medici (Medici) 13 May 1567 Florence, Italy 19 Jul 1621 Murano, Veneto, Italy Male Marchal-178
Q1587522 Don Giovanni de' Medici (Italian military commander and diplomat (1567-1621)) 23 May 1567 Florence Italy 19 Jul 1621 Murano Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 08.06.2021 16:18:24 False suggestion Date is correct
Bentivoglio-7
H
12 Feb 1443 Giovanni Giovanni II Bentivoglio 15 Feb 1443 Bologna, Italy 16 Feb 1508 Milan, Italy Male Orphan
Q194996 Giovanni II Bentivoglio (Italian noble (1443-1508)) 12 Feb 1443 Bologna Italy 15 Feb 1508 Milan Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 11.05.2021 16:10:18 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Luxembourg-101
H
12 Jul 1275 Henri Heinrich VII Kaiser des Heiligen Römischen Reiches de Luxembourg (Luxembourg) uncertain 1279 Valenciennes, Hainaut 24 Aug 1313 Nuonconvento, Italy Male WikiTree-53

Heinzelmann-5

Atkinson-107
Q152717 Henry VII, Holy Roman Emperor (King of the Romans from 1308 to 1313) 12 Jul 1275 Valenciennes France 24 Aug 1313 Buonconvento Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thiessen-117 13.01.2021 00:09:06 False suggestion 2 different wikis 2 diff dates ...
Medici-55
H
Sep 1542 Isabella de Medici (Medici) 31 Aug 1542 Florence, Tuscany, Italy 16 Jul 1576 Cerreto Guidi, Province of Florence, Tuscany, Italy Female Marchal-178
Q271831 Isabella de' Medici (daughter of Cosimo I. de’ Medici and Eleonora of Toledo (1542-1576)) Sep 1542 Florence Italy 16 Jul 1576 Cerreto Guidi Italy female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 28.04.2021 09:25:36 False suggestion Suggestion info is false, wikidata is correct
Scott-34785
H
1834 Marcella Ella MacTavish (Scott) certain 21 Jan 1833 certain Elizabeth, Union, New Jersey, United States 17 Feb 1909 certain Rome, Italy Female Brodeur-242
Q85323326 Marcella Scott ((1833-1909)) 1834 1909 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Brodeur-242 26.12.2021 16:04:51 Corrected
brodeur-242 10.01.2022 00:00:33 Not corrected Wikidata date is incorrect
brodeur-242 10.01.2022 00:00:52 False suggestion
Bayern-78
H
10 Jan 1442 Margareta von Bayern (Bayern) 1 Jan 1442 Munich, Heiliges Römisches Reich 14 Oct 1479 Mantua, Italy Female Marchal-178
Q70789 Margaret of Bavaria, Marchioness of Mantua (Marchioness consort of Mantua (1442-1479)) 10 Jan 1442 Munich Germany 23 Oct 1479 Mantua Italy female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 11.01.2022 09:38:33 False suggestion Dates are correct
Medici-54
H
13 Apr 1540 Maria Medici aka de Medici 3 Apr 1540 Firenze, Tuscany, Italy 19 Nov 1557 Livorno, Tuscany, Italia Female Howard-14814
Q1280021 Princess Maria de' Medici of Tuscany (Tuscan Royal) 13 Apr 1540 Florence Italy 29 Nov 1557 Livorno Italy female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mackinnon-507 13.10.2017 10:35:43 False suggestion Wikidata cites Russian Wikipedia in conflict with English which doesn't give a source
Miranda-308
H
6 Jul 1896 Michele Mike Miranda uncertain 26 Jul 1896 San Giuseppe Vesuviano, Naples, Italy certain 16 Sep 1973 Boca Raton, Dade County, Florida, United States Male Cascio-10
Q3856715 Michele Miranda (American mobster) 6 Jul 1896 San Giuseppe Vesuviano Italy 16 Sep 1973 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McClintock-715 11.05.2023 05:08:40 False suggestion Date is uncertain
Colonna-96
H
1405 Odoardo Colonna uncertain 1414 certain Papal States uncertain 1463 certain Cave, Italia Male Orphan
Q4228447 Odoardo Colonnà (1414 - 1485) 1405 Papal States Papal States 18 Sep 1485 Cave Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 11.08.2022 08:50:34 Corrected Corrected
Marchal-178 17.08.2022 07:38:42 False suggestion date is approximate
Medici-107
H
11 Jul 1484 Ottaviano de Medici (Medici) uncertain 14 Jul 1484 certain Italia certain 28 May 1546 certain Italia Male Marchal-178
Q3887191 Ottaviano de' Medici (Italian politician) 11 Jul 1484 28 May 1546 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 01.06.2022 09:36:53 Corrected Corrected
Marchal-178 15.06.2022 09:50:05 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Medici-58
H
7 Aug 1546 Pietro Pedricco de Medici (Medici) 10 Aug 1546 Florence, Italy 10 Jun 1547 Florence, Italy Male Marchal-178
Q3898619 Pedricco de' Medici ((1546-1547)) 7 Aug 1546 Florence Italy 9 Jun 1547 Florence Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 08.06.2021 16:00:44 False suggestion names and dates are correct
Von Leuchtenberg-5
H
16 Jul 1890 Sergei Herzog von Leuchtenberg certain 4 Jul 1890 Peterhof Russia certain 7 Jan 1974 Rome Italy Male Rosner-239
Q4417000 Sergei Georgievich, 8th Duke of Leuchtenberg (German noble (1890-1974)) 16 Jul 1890 Petergof Russia 7 Jan 1974 Rome Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 03.04.2019 20:00:04 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Parkyns-39
H
1798 Sir Thomas Boultbee Parkyns certain 4 Sep 1797 certain Sutton Bonington St Michael, Nottinghamshire, England certain 1833 certain Italy Male Boultbee-189
Q76275059 Thomas Boultbee Parkyns ((1798-1833)) 1798 1833 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 02.11.2021 16:44:58 False suggestion Wikitree date is supported by baptism source
Mowbray-12
H
1366 Thomas Duke of Norfolk, Earl of Nottingham, Lord Mowbray, Lord Segrave, Earl Marshal of England de Mowbray (Mowbray) KG uncertain 22 Mar 1367 England 22 Sep 1399 Venice, Italy Male Noland-165

Wood-2151
Q711992 Thomas de Mowbray, 1st Duke of Norfolk (English peer (1366-1399)) 1366 Epworth Epworth Kingdom of England United Kingdom 22 Sep 1399 Venice Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 08.02.2020 03:29:07 False suggestion see WikiTree profile for details of his birth date. Also, 1366 is not correct for the datafield (it's old style & WikiTree uses new style in datafield)
Gagliano-11
H
29 May 1884 Tommaso Tommy Thomas Gagliano certain 29 May 1883 Corleone, Palermo, Italy certain 16 Feb 1951 certain Valley Stream, Hempstead, Nassau, New York, United States Male Cascio-10
Q922816 Tommy Gagliano (American mobster) 29 May 1884 Sicily Italy 16 Feb 1951 New York City United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McNamee-238 08.03.2020 15:50:31 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Capone-3
H
28 Mar 1892 Vincenzo Richard James Two-Gun Hart (Capone) May 1892 certain Italy 1 Oct 1952 Homer, Dakota, Nebraska, United States Male Ciaramella Luco-2
Q428446 Vincenzo Capone (brother of Al Capone) 28 Mar 1892 Angri Italy 1 Oct 1952 Homer United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mason-10934 10.09.2019 18:34:48 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced, WikiTree date from 1900 census
Makeba-1
H
3 Mar 1932 Zenzile Miriam Miriam Makeba certain 4 Mar 1932 Prospect Township, Johannesburg, Union of South Africa certain 9 Nov 2008 Castel Volturno, Caserta, Campania, Italy Female Burch-2229
Q146256 Miriam Makeba (South African singer and civil rights activist (1932–2008)) 3 Mar 1932 Johannesburg South Africa 9 Nov 2008 Castel Volturno Italy female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
burch-2229 29.03.2023 23:02:52 False suggestion wikipedia and f.a.g say 4 march