Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 210: Father was dead before birth Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Mac Murchadha Caomhánach-2
H
Sir Murchadh Morgan Mac Murchadha Caomhánach aka MacMurrough Kavanagh Father Ireland 1643 Spain Male Brown-113775

Hennigan-514
Kavanaugh-38
H
Philemon Kavanaugh Sr. Child uncertain 1690 Europe certain 1743 certain St Marks Parish, Orange, Virginia Male Nicely-83

Eddings-305

Middleton-1819
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Eddings-305 30.08.2023 01:42:38 Not corrected Left a comment on the profile.
Richards-7070 06.01.2024 16:17:57 False suggestion
Carleton-1209
H
Lancelot Carleton Father 1695 Male Tarleton-458
Carleton-214
H
Christopher Carleton Child uncertain 1700 Enniskillen, County Fermanagh, Ireland certain 1739 certain Newry, County Down, Ireland Male Jewett-369
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jewett-369 05.12.2023 18:29:50 False suggestion
Boak-276
H
Unknown Boak Father after 1775 Male Glover-9991
Boak-277
H
John Boak Child uncertain 1777 County Tyrone, Ireland before 1820 Male Glover-9991
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Glover-9991 09.01.2024 20:02:30 False suggestion date of death is marked 'after', not exact, so there's no conflict
Boak-276
H
Unknown Boak Father after 1775 Male Glover-9991
Boak-283
H
William Boak Child 1780 County Tyrone, Ireland Male Glover-9991
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Glover-9991 09.01.2024 20:02:30 False suggestion date of death is marked 'after', not exact, so there's no conflict
Rice-1286
H
Dominick Rice Father uncertain 1564 uncertain Dingle, County Kerry, Ireland certain 1592 Dingle, County Kerry, Ireland Male Carson-514
Rice-1291
H
James Rice Child 1596 Dingle, Kerry, , Ireland Male Carson-514
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Pieterse-13 09.04.2019 16:58:54 Corrected
Knox-4407 29.09.2021 18:44:58 False suggestion
Munro-534
H
George Munro Ist Laird of Obsdale (Munro) Father uncertain 1565 Scotland uncertain 1589 Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Munro-3086
H
Robert Munro Child uncertain 1601 Ross-shire, Scotland certain 1680 County Down, Ireland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Toemmes-1 08.04.2022 21:48:59 False suggestion
Pike-3575
H
Alexander Pike Father certain 14 Dec 1596 uncertain 1645 Limerick, Ireland Male Harvel-42
Pike-279
H
Gabriel Pike Child uncertain 1650 certain Ireland not living uncertain North Carolina Male Pike-2301
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Doss-1813 15.06.2023 15:50:06 False suggestion
Simpson-24734
H
William Simpson Father uncertain 1620 uncertain Scotland after 1694 uncertain Ireland Male Ross-19791
Simpson-13581
H
Sarah Campbell (Simpson) aka Thompson Child uncertain 1696 Londonderry, County Londonderry, Ireland uncertain 1775 certain Cherry Valley, Otsego, New York Female Browne-2174
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ross-19791 21.02.2023 17:46:09 Comment Daughter's birth date is unknown/unconfirmed, her father would have been alive at her conception, however as her birth date is unknown, approx date of conception is also unknown
Ross-19791 01.03.2023 17:17:41 False suggestion
FitzSimon-61
H
Thomas FitzSimon Father before 1650 County Dublin, Ireland before 1678 uncertain County Dublin, Ireland Male Carson-3914
Fitzsimon-52
H
Raymond Fitzsimon Child before 1680 certain 26 Feb 1744 County Dublin, Ireland Male Falvey-115

Carson-3914
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 13.04.2021 16:36:41 False suggestion before 1680 can also be before 1678
Hickey-1520
H
William Hickey Father uncertain 6 May 1740 certain Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland 1 Jan 1775 uncertain Male Hennessy-434
Hickey-1527
H
Joseph Hickey Child 16 Sep 1870 Doneraile, Cork, Ireland Male Hennessy-434
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hickey-3077 08.11.2022 23:51:18 False suggestion
McChoey-1
H
Lawrence Lawe McChoey Father before 1796 after 1796 Male Matthews-10015
McCooey-146
H
Arthur McCooey Child uncertain 1800 Upper Creggan, County Armagh, Ireland Male Matthews-10015
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Matthews-10015 12.12.2021 16:27:02 False suggestion
Coughlin-867
H
Thomas Coughlin Father before 1810 Ireland uncertain 1835 certain Ireland Male Murray-17973
Caughlin-98
H
John Caughlin Child before 1839 Ireland Male Murray-17973
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Murray-17973 22.02.2021 00:21:46 False suggestion date of death is marked 'after', not exact, so there's no conflict
Foster-36877
H
Abraham Foster Father 1810 Skreen, County Sligo, Ireland 30 May 1869 Kingston, Frontenac, Ontario, Canada Male Fiordalisi-11
Foster-36881
H
Mary Rudolph Foster Child 28 Sep 1886 Kingston, Frontenac, Ontario, Canada 6 Jun 1890 Kingston, Frontenac, Ontario, Canada Female Fiordalisi-11
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Whittington-2355 30.04.2024 07:22:52 Corrected Corrected relationships
Ryan-21149
H
Edward Ryan Father 1812 Ireland 27 Nov 1883 certain Wisconsin, United States Male Spencer-24565
Ryan-21148
H
Joseph A Ryan Child certain 6 Sep 1895 certain Wisconsin, United States certain 11 Apr 1934 uncertain Wisconsin, United States Male Spencer-24565
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Whittington-2355 30.04.2024 07:34:32 Corrected
Whittington-2355 30.04.2024 07:36:18 Corrected Corrected birth date
Reese-440
H
John Davis Reese Father 4 Mar 1815 Newbridge, Glamorgan, Wales, United Kingdom 19 Mar 1880 Malad, Oneida, Idaho, United States Male Orphan
Reese-451
H
Robert Reese Child 21 Mar 1881 Malad City, Oneida, Idaho, United States 9 Jan 1955 Brigham City, Box Elder, Utah, United States Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Crook-641 22.08.2018 18:54:21 False suggestion Dad died shortly before he was born, but after he was created.
Crook-641 29.08.2018 15:54:09 False suggestion Father died two days before his son was born. He was, however, alive at the conception.
Rudderham-80 23.02.2021 17:19:16 Comment Left a comment on the profile.
Fardy-30
H
Patritius Patrick Fardy Father uncertain 1818 certain Wexford, Ireland certain 11 Apr 1852 certain Louisa Creek, New South Wales, Australia Male Hackett-970
Fardy-67
H
Richard Fardy Child uncertain 1856 certain Bathurst, New South Wales, Australia certain 3 May 1918 certain Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia Male McCarron-898
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McCarron-858 08.02.2019 02:40:34 False suggestion Not biological father but was known as his son. See DC
Sharpe-4326
H
William Sharpe Father uncertain 1820 Ireland uncertain 28 Apr 1864 Canada Male Sharpe-986
Sharpe-4340
H
Anne Sharpe Child uncertain 9 Jun 1865 Pontiac, Quebec certain 11 Sep 1936 Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada Female Sharpe-986
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Sharpe-986 18.03.2022 20:33:41 False suggestion Several records (census and marriages) indicate di
Gallaher-419
H
Edward F Gallaher Jr Father certain 1829 County Sligo, Ireland certain 26 Feb 1878 Augusta, GA Male Roach-1540
Gallaher-453
H
Louis Gallaher Child 18 Sep 1879 Augusta, GA Jun 1963 Savannah, GA Male Roach-1540
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Harwood-2709 07.11.2021 00:37:29 False suggestion both dates are correct. Father died prior to birth and mother remarried
Davidson-8883
H
George Davidson Father uncertain 1847 uncertain Donaghmore, County Tyrone, Ireland certain 27 Apr 1882 certain Ballybray, Donaghmore, County Tyrone, Ireland Male Davidson-8855
Davidson-9633
H
Maggie Calderwood (Davidson) Child Apr 1915 Gortnaglush, Donaghmore, Co. Tyrone, Ireland 1995 Newmills, Dungannon, Co. Tyrone, Northern Ireland Female Davidson-8855
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Davidson-8855 17.09.2021 23:14:47 False suggestion
Davidson-8883
H
George Davidson Father uncertain 1847 uncertain Donaghmore, County Tyrone, Ireland certain 27 Apr 1882 certain Ballybray, Donaghmore, County Tyrone, Ireland Male Davidson-8855
McMinn-868
H
Margaret Jackson (McMinn) Child 12 Dec 1894 17 Nov 1973 Female Davidson-8855
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Davidson-8855 17.09.2021 23:14:54 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Neill-615
H
Patrick O'Neill (Neill) Father 1872 Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland 6 Feb 1908 Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland Male Kennerk-118
ONeill-183
H
Christina ONeill Child 7 Jan 1911 Dublin, Ireland 17 Apr 2006 Dublin, Ireland Female Kennerk-118
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 29.04.2018 18:13:45 False suggestion narrative in bio gives detailed info
Kelly-31
H
Patrick Kelly Father 27 Jan 1873 Clonduff, County Down, Ireland 16 Jun 1906 Dublin, Ireland Male Nunnally-9
Kelly-30
H
Margaret Cavanagh (Kelly) Child uncertain 6 Dec 1908 uncertain Dublin, Ireland 7 Oct 2002 uncertain Dublin, Ireland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 21.12.2018 18:00:17 False suggestion both dates are correct.
Fields-1741
H
John Johnny Fields Father uncertain 1878 uncertain Lifford, County Donegal, Ireland after 1911 uncertain Male Mc Laughlin-54

Doyle-1868
Fields-1601
H
Eileen Hamilton (Fields) Child certain 1920s certain 1970s Female Doyle-1868
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cottrell-943 28.09.2018 18:22:17 False suggestion Death date for father is after 1911
Hughes-18315
H
John Hughes Father uncertain 1893 Ireland after 1929 Ohio, USA Male Orphan
Hughes-18378
H
Robert John Hughes Child 7 Mar 1931 Warren, Trumbull, Ohio, USA 15 Aug 2001 Warren, Trumbull, Ohio, USA Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rodgers-4151 01.10.2019 20:37:12 False suggestion date of death is marked 'after', not exact, so there's no conflict