Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 557: Wikidata - Imprecise death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Campbell-34448
H
21 Jun 1877 Alexander Campbell 1833 Dungloe, Templecrone, County Donegal, Ireland 1877 Mauch Chunk Township, Carbon, Pennsylvania, United States Male Smith-121775
Q3818144 Alexander Campbell (tavern owner and criminal) 1833 Dungloe Republic of Ireland 21 Jun 1877 Jim Thorpe United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Smith-121775 26.04.2020 22:48:48 False suggestion Mauch Chunk was the original name of JIm Thorpe and was the correct name when the death occured.
Dopping-12
H
15 Jul 1794 Anthony Dopping Esq before 22 Sep 1714 County Westmeath, Ireland Jul 1794 Lowtown, County Westmeath, Ireland Male Rounsefell-5
Q75426451 Anthony Dopping ((1714-1794)) 13 Sep 1714 15 Jul 1794 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rounsefell-5 30.05.2022 06:10:17 False suggestion Wikidata only has the peerage as a source, no primary source found
O'Neill-1566
H
16 May 1260 Brian Catha an Duin Brian Ruaidh High King of Ireland O'Neill aka Prince of Tyrone uncertain 1200 certain county Tyrone, Ireland certain 1260 certain Downpatrick, County Down, Ireland Male WikiTree-34
Q976010 Brian O'Neill (King of Tir Eoghain) 1220 16 May 1260 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Willis-3607 04.05.2019 13:54:16 False suggestion the 'precise death date' quoted is that for the battle than occurred on or about that date - person died as a result of battle 'on or about' 16th May 1260; therefore no precise date possible
Shackleton-372
H
11 May 1958 Clara L Shackleton certain 7 Feb 1881 Dublin, Ireland certain 1958 Surrey, England Female Gierszewski-4
Q75785084 Clara Willian Shackleton ((1881-1958)) 7 Feb 1881 11 May 1958 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gierszewski-4 11.12.2019 04:40:59 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Mac Áedo-6
H
Jan 642 Domnall High King of Ireland mac Áedo uncertain 570 uncertain Ireland 642 uncertain Ireland Male WikiTree-34

Devlin-670
Q1154319 Domnall mac Áedo (7th-century Irish monarch) 5cen Republic of Ireland Republic of Ireland Jan 642 Republic of Ireland Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
devlin-670 14.05.2021 19:23:55 False suggestion Wikidata gives no source
MacCarthy-110
H
1 Dec 1206 Donal Mór Na Curra King of Desmond MacCarthy 1138 Munster, Ireland certain 1206 Kilbrin, County Cork, Ireland Male WikiTree-34
Q84148411 Domnall Mór mac Diarmata ((1138-1206)) 1 Dec 1206 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Devlin-670 25.04.2020 17:48:24 False suggestion Wrong Person
FitzGerald-6407
H
17 May 1836 Gerald FitzGerald 11 Oct 1803 Tarbert, County Kerry, Ireland 1836 Vitoria, Álava, Basque Country, Spain Male Falvey-115
Q75894687 Gerald Fitzgerald ((1803-1836)) 1803 17 May 1836 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 25.08.2020 18:50:59 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong, that is the date of the press report
Shackleton-369
H
20 Sep 1938 Gertrude A Shackleton certain 24 Nov 1872 certain County Kildare, Ireland uncertain 1938 Lewisham, London, England Female Gierszewski-4
Q75785193 Gertrude Alice Shackleton ((1872-1938)) 24 Nov 1872 20 Sep 1938 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gierszewski-4 11.12.2019 04:39:55 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Persse-84
H
14 Feb 1876 Gertrude Beauchamp (Persse) uncertain 1841 Ireland certain Feb 1876 certain Trevince, Gwennap, Cornwall, England Female Farler-25
Q75992098 Gertrude Persse ((1841-1876)) 1841 14 Feb 1876 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Farler-25 24.10.2021 14:34:35 False suggestion FindAGrave record is unsourced. Pleas do not use FindAGrave for suggestions as it is so often in error or just unsourced.
Farler-25 24.10.2021 14:36:35 False suggestion Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced, again a waste of my time
Clinton-466
H
24 Jan 1718 James Clinton uncertain 1667 uncertain England uncertain 1718 uncertain Ireland Male Sims-1440

Markee-4

WikiTree-6

Thompson-8001

Thompson-8328

Fremon-1
Q6131479 James Clinton (Irish soldier and politician) 1667 Ireland Ireland Republic of Ireland United Kingdom 24 Jan 1718 County Longford Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 14.08.2019 00:07:56 False suggestion No source for specific date
FitzGerald-4273
H
11 Oct 1399 John 4th Earl of Desmond FitzGerald after 1366 Ireland certain Oct 1399 Ardfinnan, County Tipperary, Ireland Male WikiTree-34
Q6233271 John FitzGerald, 4th Earl of Desmond (English nobleman) 13cen 11 Oct 1399 Ardfinnan Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Devlin-670 25.04.2020 17:46:09 False suggestion Where did Wikidata get such a precise date? i added the correct Date.
D'Arcy-1396
H
Feb 1766 Judge D'Arcy before 28 Oct 1729 County Westmeath, Ireland certain 1766 Grange Beg, County Westmeath, Ireland Male Rounsefell-5
Q75883457 Judge D'Arcy ((1729-1766)) 20 Sep 1729 Feb 1766 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
rounsefell-5 28.05.2022 21:33:49 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Chapman-5316
H
25 Jan 1889 William Chapman 1811 certain County Westmeath, Ireland 1889 Male Farler-25
Q75569071 William Chapman ((1811-1889)) 4 Nov 1811 25 Jan 1889 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Farler-25 18.02.2021 22:43:34 False suggestion Wikidata is Unsourced