Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Sherman-8593
H
22 Sep 1903 Alson Smith Sherman 21 Apr 1811 Barre, Washington County, Vermont, United States 22 Aug 1903 Waukegan, Lake County, Illinois, United States Male Smith-62120
Q295285 Alson Sherman (American politician (1811–1903)) 21 Apr 1811 Barre United States of America 22 Sep 1903 Waukegan United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Smith-62120 03.08.2022 03:41:34 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong
Greenleaf-161
H
16 Sep 1842 Anna Nancy Nancy Cranch (Greenleaf) 3 Jun 1772 16 Sep 1843 Washington, Washington County, District of Columbia, United States Female Orphan
Q87838551 Nancy Greenleaf Cranch ((1772-1842)) 3 Jun 1772 16 Sep 1842 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rice-16143 16.04.2022 06:32:59 False suggestion
Condon-597
H
5 Nov 1916 Clarence Melville Condon 12 Aug 1875 Brooksville, Hancock, Maine, USA 20 Jul 1916 Washington, DC Male Sibley-190
Q5126648 Clarence M. Condon (United States Army Medal of Honor recipient) 12 Aug 1875 Brooksville United States of America 5 Nov 1916 Walter Reed Army Medical Center United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Sibley-190 24.08.2017 22:16:00 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Lindley-480
H
22 Jun 1818 Pvt. Demas Lindly (Lindley) aka Lindsley , Lindley certain 3 Jun 1733 Morristown, Morris, New Jersey certain 22 Jan 1818 Washington County, Pennsylvania, United States Male Sanders-3287

Sanders-1888
Q107986667 Demas Lindley ((1733-1818)) 3 Jun 1733 22 Jun 1818 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Sanders-1888 09.12.2021 04:00:30 False suggestion
Pennebaker-45
H
16 Aug 1954 Dorothy Julia Dodie Brando (Pennebaker) certain 20 Jan 1897 certain Grand Island, Hall, Nebraska, United States certain 31 Mar 1954 certain Pasadena, Los Angeles, California, United States Female Djerf-8
Q3033660 Dodie Brando (American actress (1897-1954)) 7 Feb 1897 Omaha United States of America 16 Aug 1954 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
selbrede-2 21.05.2017 23:47:00 Not corrected conflict between sources
Djerf-8 28.01.2020 23:02:41 False suggestion Wikidata data is correct as per sources on profile
Sumner-3944
H
12 Jan 1954 Francis Cecil Sumner certain 7 Dec 1895 certain Pine Bluff, Jefferson, Arkansas, USA certain 11 Jan 1954 certain Washington, District of Columbia, USA Male WikiTree-112

McBeth-165
Q5482532 Francis Sumner (American psychologist (1895-1954)) 7 Dec 1895 Pine Bluff United States of America 12 Jan 1954 Washington, D.C. United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Honey-866 10.11.2023 19:02:43 False suggestion
Stanton-140
H
1 Apr 1778 Hannah Babcock (Stanton) 1714 Stonington, New London County, Connecticut certain 19 Sep 1778 Westerly, Washington, Rhode Island, United States Female Cohen-96
Q96195489 Hannah Stanton Babcock ((1714-1778)) 1714 1 Apr 1778 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Pendleton-1947 06.03.2021 20:32:28 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Muir-2267
H
7 Jun 1964 Helen Lillian Muir aka Funk certain 23 Jan 1886 certain Martinez, Contra Costa, California, United States certain 17 Jun 1964 certain Spokane, Spokane, Washington, United States Female Metcalf-1784
Q22672193 Helen Muir Funk ((1886-1964)) 23 Jan 1886 7 Jun 1964 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Metcalf-1784 19.12.2017 21:04:27 False suggestion Wikipedia is incorrect. Correct death date is 17 June. I have added additional source (Sierr Club) to profile.
Garfield-38
H
19 Jul 1951 Irvin McDowell Garfield 3 Aug 1870 Washington City, District Of Columbia, District of Columbia, USA certain 18 Jul 1951 Boston, Suffolk, Massachusetts, United States Male WikiTree-6
Q75766699 Irvin McDowell Garfield ((1870-1951)) 3 Aug 1870 Hiram United States of America 19 Jul 1951 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 15.12.2019 23:33:38 False suggestion Wikidata/thepeerage is unsourced
Brent-918
H
27 Oct 1962 John Edmonson Brent certain 8 Aug 1889 certain Washington, District of Columbia, United States certain 22 Oct 1962 certain Buffalo, Erie, New York, United States Male WikiTree-112
Q111676943 John E. Brent (born 8 Aug 1889; died 27 Oct 1962) 8 Aug 1889 27 Oct 1962 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ward-9858 10.09.2022 22:26:16 False suggestion
Washington-80
H
1677 Col. John Washington certain 1634 uncertain Purleigh, Essex, England before 11 Jan 1678 Washington Parish, Westmoreland County, Colony of Virginia Male WikiTree-36

WikiTree-6
Q3182695 John Washington (English planter, soldier, politician, and the great-grandfather of George Washington) 1633 Tring Purleigh United Kingdom United Kingdom 1677 Westmoreland County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-167 30.10.2019 16:38:09 False suggestion both are correct; WikiTree uses the date will was proved (11 Jan. 1677/8) as 'died before' date... will was wriiten 1775. He is believed to have died September 1677 (WikiTree profile), but all Wikipedia has is '1677 (aged 46) Washington Parish, Westmoreland County, Colony of Virginia' - with no source citation.
Casey-731
H
3 Feb 1807 BGen Levi Garrett Casey certain 1749 certain Old 96 District, now Newberry District, South Carolina certain 1 Feb 1807 certain Washington, District of Columbia, United States Male Murray-10306

Peebles-1436

Grant-3042
Q1821849 Levi Casey (American politician (1752-1807)) 1752 South Carolina United States of America 3 Feb 1807 Washington, D.C. United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Murray-10306 19.07.2017 23:50:54 False suggestion Death occured on 1 Feb, he was buried 3 Feb; error in several records; project protected
Bowen-1185
H
17 Mar 1873 Louisa Smith Johnston (Bowen) 16 Feb 1800 Washington Co., Virginia 17 Sep 1873 Abingdon, Washington Co., Virginia Female Richards-12736
Q108138794 Louisa Smith Johnston ((1800-1873)) 16 Feb 1800 17 Mar 1873 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richards-12736 27.02.2022 19:15:20 Corrected corrected death date to match FindAGrave
Richards-12736 12.08.2023 18:48:00 Corrected Memorial number was from father's FAG memorial.
Richards-12736 12.08.2023 18:48:33 Comment
Richards-12736 13.11.2023 15:43:37 Corrected
Richards-12736 01.02.2024 17:45:38 False suggestion
Doyle-6954
H
29 Nov 1989 Mabel Elouise Staupers (Doyle) aka Keaton certain 27 Feb 1890 certain Barbados, British West Indies certain 30 Sep 1989 certain Washington, District of Columbia, United States Female WikiTree-112
Q6721463 Mabel Keaton Staupers (American nurse and activist (1890-1989)) 27 Feb 1890 Barbados Barbados 29 Nov 1989 Washington, D.C. United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Weatherall-96 26.04.2021 00:35:29 False suggestion 30 Sep is correct, per national newspapers and SSDI. FindaGrave, WikiData, and Encyclopedia Brittanica online are all incorrect, likely initial wrong source is FindAGrave. I plan to contact all of these for correction.
Trimmer-165
H
18 Mar 1865 Margaret Ann Nixon (Trimmer) 1826 certain Pennsylvania, United States certain 19 Mar 1865 Vinton, Ohio, United States Female Harbaugh-249

WikiTree-6
Q75763403 Margaret Ann Trimmer ((1826-1865)) 1826 18 Mar 1865 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.12.2019 21:23:19 False suggestion Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced, WikiTree is based on death record
Thurston-3293
H
1931 Margaret Carter Twigg-Smith (Thurston) certain 17 Jan 1895 Washington, District of Columbia, United States certain 20 Jul 1976 Holualoa, Hawaii, Hawaii, United States Female Orphan
Q19849300 Margaret Twigg-Smith ((1895-1931)) 1895 1931 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
burch-2229 10.06.2022 02:27:39 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect; she is in 1940 census
Lincoln-623
H
1882 Mrs Mary Ada Crume (Lincoln) certain 20 Jan 1775 certain Linville Creek, Rockingham County, Virginia uncertain 1832 certain Breckinridge County, Kentucky Female Altic-1

Hamilton-1467
Q6780090 Mary Lincoln Crume (Aunt of Abraham Lincoln) 1775 Augusta County United States of America 1882 Breckinridge County United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cullen-643 27.07.2017 19:37:01 False suggestion No sources
DiSalle-1
H
15 Sep 1981 Michael Vincent Michele DiSalle certain 6 Jan 1908 certain New York City, New York, United States 16 Sep 1981 certain Pescara, Pescara, Abruzzo, Italy Male Maier-1517
Q374509 Michael DiSalle (American mayor (1908-1981)) 6 Jan 1908 New York City United States of America 15 Sep 1981 14 Sep 1981 Italy Italy male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Melick-229 01.04.2023 22:48:14 False suggestion Profile has sources for this date
Lincoln-281
H
Dec 1736 Mordecai Lincoln II 24 Apr 1686 Hingham, Plymouth, Massachusetts 12 May 1736 Amity, Washington, Pennsylvania Male Lee-5956

Moore-13875

WikiTree-6

Sheehan-26

Altic-1

Wallace-2451
Q75763876 Mordecai Lincoln, Jr. ((1686-1736)) 24 Apr 1686 Dec 1736 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 13.03.2020 23:41:06 False suggestion Wikidata gives no source
Rinzler-4
H
2 Jul 1994 Ralph Charles Rinzler 20 Jul 1934 Passaic, New Jersey, United States 15 Jul 1994 Washington D.C., United States Male WikiTree-130

Craig-4574
Q7288020 Ralph Rinzler (American festival organizer (1934–1994)) 20 Jul 1934 2 Jul 1994 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 20.09.2023 12:49:28 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Ross-30242
H
18 Mar 1999 Dr. Russell Ross certain 25 May 1929 certain St. Augustine, St. Johns, Florida, United States certain 15 Mar 1999 certain Seattle, King, Washington, United States Male Orphan
Q30146495 Russell Ross (American Pathologist, PhD) 25 May 1929 St. Augustine United States of America 18 Mar 1999 Seattle United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marsh-9608 17.01.2023 22:03:37 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Ritter-4161
H
21 May 1952 William McClellan Ritter certain 19 Feb 1864 certain Franklin Township, Lycoming, Pennsylvania, United States certain 16 May 1952 Washington, District of Columbia, United States Male Stewart-763

WikiTree-130
Q111570139 William McClellan Ritter (American businessman (1864–1952)) 19 Feb 1864 21 May 1952 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 26.04.2024 17:09:52 False suggestion Wikitree date is correct
Adair-2246
H
23 Oct 1880 Col. William Penn Adair certain 15 Apr 1830 Cherokee Nation (East) certain 21 Oct 1880 Washington, District of Columbia, United States Male Kemp-4435
Q49304 William Penn Adair (Cherokee leader and Confederate colonel) 1828 15 Apr 1830 23 Oct 1880 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parks-2399 01.07.2020 14:55:56 False suggestion
West-3863
H
1814 Brig. Gen. William West certain 1733 North Kingstown, Washington County, Rhode Island certain 1816 Scituate, Providence County, Rhode Island, USA Male B-404
Q8020206 William West (American politician, Rhode Island) 1733 North Kingstown United States of America 1814 Scituate United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID1130317 15.11.2016 00:05:56 False suggestion Old False error