Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Warning 563: Wikidata - Possible duplicate by father Help (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Vermandois-196
H 		Compare Adalbert Adalbert I Comte de Vermandois de Vermandois (Vermandois) Wikitree Father uncertain 924 Vermandois, France uncertain 8 Sep 987 St. Quentin, Vermandois, France Male VanderLeest-211

Lamoreaux-297
Vermandois-13
H 		Heribert Heribert II Count of Vermandois, Meaux and Soissons de Vermandois (Vermandois) Wikidata Father uncertain 880 uncertain Vermandois, France certain 23 Feb 943 uncertain St Quentin, Peronne, Somme, France Male VanderLeest-211

WikiTree-113

Atkinson-107
Q513843 Herbert II, Count of Vermandois (Frankish noble from Carolingian dynastys.) 880 23 Feb 943 male
Q2369226 Guy I of Vermandois (Count of Soissons) 988 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 05.10.2021 22:10:25 False suggestion Father and son - no duplicates
Carolingian-138
H 		Compare Charles Duke of Lower Lotharingia Lotharingia (Carolingian) aka Basse-Lotharingie Wikitree Father certain 953 Laon, France 21 May 992 Orléans, France Male WikiTree-113
Carolingien-26
H 		Otto Duc de Basse-Lorraine Carolingian (Carolingien) Wikidata Father uncertain 970 Lower Lorraine, France uncertain 13 Jun 1014 Maastricht Male Orphan
Q699248 Otto II , Duke of Lower Lorraine (French duke) 970 1012 Maastricht Netherlands male
Q990836 Ermengarde of Lower Lotharingia (consort countess of Namur) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2746736 21.02.2017 15:16:45 False suggestion Old False error
Percy-23
H 		Compare Sir Henry 5th Lord Percy, 2nd Earl of Northumberland, Constable of England Warden of the Marches of Scotland Percy Wikitree Father certain 3 Feb 1392 certain Warkworth, Northumberland, England certain 22 May 1455 St. Albans, Hertfordshire, England Male Lockwood-1016
Percy-44
H 		Sir Henry 3rd Earl of Northumberland, 6th Lord Percy Percy Wikidata Father certain 25 Jul 1421 certain Leconfield, Yorkshire, England certain 29 Mar 1461 certain Battle of Towton, Towton, Yorkshire, England Male WikiTree-113

Stewart-6071
Q75446916 Lady Anne Percy (Peerage person ID=147159) 1436 5 Jul 1522 female
Q2521911 Henry Percy, 3rd Earl of Northumberland (English noble) 25 Jul 1421 Leconfield United Kingdom 29 Mar 1461 Battle of Towton Kingdom of England male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 15.09.2021 14:20:09 False suggestion Those are two different profiles.
Carolingian-76
H 		Compare Hludowic Louis I Holy Roman Emperor of France (Carolingian) Wikitree Father uncertain Sep 778 certain Casseneuil, Lot-et-Garonne, Aquitaine, France 20 Jun 840 Ingelheim, Mainz-Bingen, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany Male WikiTree-113

Atkinson-107

VanderLeest-211
Carolingian-77
H 		Charles Charlemagne Karolus Magnus, King of the Franks, Emperor of the Romans Carolingian Wikidata Father uncertain 2 Apr 748 certain Austrasia, Francia certain 28 Jan 814 Aachen, Austrasia, Francia Male WikiTree-113

VanderLeest-211

Athey-67

Atkinson-107

Cayley-55
Q3044 Charlemagne (king of Franks, regarded as the first Holy Roman Emperor (747–814)) 742 10 Apr 742 10 Apr 742 742 742 2 Apr 748 10 Apr 742 740s 747 2 Apr 742 740s 747 742 747 2 Apr 742 742 2 Apr 748 740s 2 Apr 742 747 2 Apr 742 747 747 742 747 2 Apr 748 2 Apr 748 740s 10 Apr 742 747 2 Apr 748 10 Apr 742 10 Apr 742 742 2 Apr 742 2 Apr 748 10 Apr 742 2 Apr 748 10 Apr 742 742 740s 2 Apr 742 2 Apr 748 740s Francia Francia Francia France 1 Feb 814 1 Feb 814 1 Feb 814 28 Jan 814 28 Jan 814 28 Jan 814 1 Feb 814 28 Jan 814 Aachen Germany male
Q23930949 Alpais (frankish princess daughter of Charlemagne) 794 794 794 794 852 852 852 852 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 16.05.2021 20:40:04 False suggestion Nonsense
Bermingham-134
H 		Compare Piers 1st Lord Athenry Bermingham aka MacPhioris Wikitree Father 2 Apr 1307 Male WikiTree-113
Bermingham-174
H 		Piers de Bermingham (Bermingham) Wikidata Father uncertain 1260 uncertain Thetmoy, Ireland before 1303 Male Hunt-2329
Q75290529 Piers FitzJames MacPhioris de Bermingham (Peerage person ID=41824) 1260 male
Q75872628 Bridget de Bermingham (Peerage person ID=370900) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hunt-2329 21.01.2022 12:04:46 False suggestion Different people
Courtenay-435
H 		Compare Renaud Reynold de Courtenay (Courtenay) Wikitree Father uncertain 1098 France after 1161 England Male Atkinson-107
Courtenay-57
H 		Renaud de Courtenay (Courtenay) Wikidata Father uncertain 1100 Courtenay, Loiret, Centre, France 27 Sep 1189 Berkshire, England Male WikiTree-113
Q2616254 Renaud de Courtenay (British noble) 1100 27 Sep 1194 male
Q75248233 Renaud de Courtenay (Peerage person ID=9310) 1140 27 Sep 1194 male
Q2616254 Renaud de Courtenay (British noble) 1100 27 Sep 1194 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 11.10.2020 17:20:05 False suggestion Different people
Courtenay-435
H 		Compare Renaud Reynold de Courtenay (Courtenay) Wikitree Father uncertain 1098 France after 1161 England Male Atkinson-107
Courtenay-57
H 		Renaud de Courtenay (Courtenay) Wikidata Father uncertain 1100 Courtenay, Loiret, Centre, France 27 Sep 1189 Berkshire, England Male WikiTree-113
Q2616254 Renaud de Courtenay (British noble) 1100 27 Sep 1194 male
Q2616254 Renaud de Courtenay (British noble) 1100 27 Sep 1194 male
Q75387840 Robert de Courtenay ((died 1209)) 1209 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 11.10.2020 17:20:05 False suggestion Different people
Flandre-30
H 		Compare Robert Robert II le Fleming de Flandre (Flandre) aka of Flanders Wikitree Father 1065 Flanders, Brussel, Belgium 5 Oct 1111 Meaux, Puy-de-Dome, Auvergne, France Male Nilsen-785
Flandre-7
H 		Baudouin Baldwin V the Pious, Count of Flanders Flandre Wikidata Father uncertain 19 Aug 1012 Flanders, Nord, Nord-Pas-de-Calais, France certain 1 Sep 1067 Lille, Nord, Nord-Pas-de-Calais, France Male Wood-2151

WikiTree-113
Q469633 Baldwin VII, Count of Flanders (Count of Flanders (1093-1119)) 1093 17 Jun 1119 Roeselare Belgium male
Q333384 Baldwin V, Count of Flanders (Count of Flanders (1012-1067)) 19 Aug 1012 Arras France 1 Sep 1067 Lille France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Nilsen-785 19.10.2023 17:24:56 False suggestion
Rous-80
H 		Compare Roger le Rous (Rous) aka Rouse Wikitree Father uncertain 1237 Harescombe, Gloucestershire, England 31 Aug 1294 uncertain Ivebrigge, Devon, England Male WikiTree-113
Mortimer-662
H 		Sir Ranulph Ralph II Baron of Wigmore, Constable of Clun Castle de Mortimer (Mortimer) Wikidata Father 15 Feb 1190 certain Wigmore Castle, Herefordshire, England 6 Aug 1246 certain Wigmore, Herefordshire, , England Male Harper-1691

Fields-574
Q61896368 Isolt de Mortimer ((1262 - uncertain 4 Aug 1338)) 1262 4 Aug 1338 female
Q7288322 Ralph de Mortimer (English marcher lord) male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 15.01.2021 18:46:46 False suggestion Unhelpful
Gant-297
H 		Compare Rudolph Rudolph I Ralph de Gent (Gant) aka de Aalst Wikitree Father uncertain 1022 County of Flanders uncertain 1058 County of Flanders Male WikiTree-113
Flandre-4
H 		Baudoin Baldwin VI - I Hainaut (Flandre) aka Count of Flanders VI, Count of Hainaut I Wikidata Father uncertain 1030 Flanders, France certain 17 Jul 1070 certain Hasnon, Nord, France Male Lamoreaux-297
Q266523 Baldwin VI, Count of Flanders (Count of Mons and Hainaut and Flanders (1030-1070)) 1030 17 Jul 1070 Hasnon France male
Q16198957 Gilbert de Gant (Anglo-Flemish noble) 1095 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 17.02.2020 02:26:50 False suggestion Definitely not the same person.
Furnival-9
H 		Compare Sir Thomas Thomas III de Furnival (Furnival) Wikitree Father after 1251 Nottinghamshire, England before 18 Apr 1332 Sheffield, Yorkshire, England Male Wood-2151
Furnival-15
H 		Thomas Thomas IV 2nd Lord Furnival de Furnival (Furnival) Wikidata Father uncertain 1292 Nottinghamshire, England certain Oct 1339 Alton, Gloucestershire, England Male WikiTree-113
Q76298239 Maud de Furnivalle (Peerage person ID=671394) 1292 1360 female
Q75922605 Thomas de Furnivalle, 2nd Baron Furnivalle (2nd Lord Furnival de Furnival (Furnival) (est. 1292 - certain Oct 1339) male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 14.10.2020 09:59:30 False suggestion Stupid
Beauchamp-109
H 		Compare William Baron of Salwarpe de Beauchamp (Beauchamp) aka de Bello Campo Wikitree Father uncertain 1210 uncertain Elmley Castle, Worcestershire, England certain 1269 uncertain Elmley Castle, Worcestershire, England Male Harper-1691

Wood-2151
Beauchamp-1147
H 		William 9th Earl of Warwick de Beauchamp (Beauchamp) Wikidata Father uncertain 1238 Warwick Castle, Warwickshire, England uncertain Jun 1298 Elmley Castle, Worcestershire, England Male WikiTree-113

Wood-2151
Q4020193 William de Beauchamp, 9th Earl of Warwick (English nobleman and soldier, Earl of Warwick) 1237 1298 male
Q75565113 Sarah de Beauchamp (Peerage person ID=215617) 1255 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 29.09.2020 11:14:27 False suggestion Different people
Рюрикович-49
H 		Compare Ярополк Святославич Yaropolk, Grand Duke of Kiev Рюрикович aka of Kiev Wikitree Father uncertain 960 Kiev, Kyiv, Kievan Rus 980 Male Orphan
Рюриковичи-2
H 		Saint Владимир Святославич Vladimir Sviatoslavich, Grand Prince of Kiev Рюрикович (Рюриковичи) of Kiev aka Rurikovich Wikidata Father uncertain 956 Kiev, Kyiv, Kievan Rus uncertain 15 Jul 1015 Berestovo, Kiev, Kyiv, Kievan Rus Male WikiTree-113
Q311575 Sviatopolk I of Kyiv (Grand Prince of Rus' (978-1019)) 979 24 Jul 1019 Poland Poland male
Q14974 Vladimir the Great (Grand Prince of Kiev) 958 956 956 958 956 956 958 958 15 Jul 1015 Berestove Ukraine male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 29.09.2021 12:08:46 False suggestion Different people