Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information .

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Wood-1167 H	1614	Major Gen. Abraham Wood		uncertain 1615 certain England	uncertain 1682 certain Charles City County, Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24
Q4669227		Abraham Wood (American fur trader)		1614 England United Kingdom	1682	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 27.04.2020 04:31:20 False suggestion wikidata cites 'English Wikipedia', which has his birth year as 1610 Noland-165 27.04.2020 04:31:30 Corrected Corrected Noland-165 27.04.2020 04:32:21 False suggestion sorry... not enough sleep. It's a False suggestion (WikiTree & Wikipedia both have 1610)
Warner-97 H	28 Nov 1610	Col. Augustine Warner Sr.		certain 28 Sep 1611 certain Norwich, Norfolk, England	certain 24 Dec 1674 certain Warner Hall, Gloucester, Colony of Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24 WikiTree-6
Q4821223		Augustine Warner (English planter and politician (1610-1674))		28 Nov 1610 Norwich United Kingdom	26 Dec 1674	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-5956 15.01.2020 22:55:23 False suggestion Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced, again a waste of my time
Dorsey-270 H	1644	Col. Edward Dorsey Jr.		uncertain 1639 certain Lower Norfolk County, Virginia Colony	before 31 Dec 1705 certain Major's Choice, Baltimore County, Province of Maryland	Male		WikiTree-24 Day-1904
Q19880332		Edward Dorsey (colonial settler of Maryland)		1644	1705	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Day-1904 14.09.2023 15:48:47 False suggestion My date estimate is better.
Strother-64 H	1700	Lt. Col. Francis Strother		uncertain 1695 certain King George, King George County, Colony of Virginia	uncertain 1752 certain Culpeper County, Colony of Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24 WikiTree-6
Q87891186		Francis Strother ((1695-1752))		1700	1751	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment prince-3397 11.02.2024 16:39:22 False suggestion message already posted
Yeardley-6 H	1587	Capt Sir George Yeardley aka Yardley, Yearley		certain 28 Jul 1588 St. Saviour's Parish, Southwark, Surrey, England	before 13 Nov 1627 Jamestown, Colony of Virginia	Male		Irby-1076 WikiTree-24 Thomas-10705
Q5546596		George Yeardley (Colonial governor of Virginia)		1587	1627	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 02.12.2021 20:20:31 False suggestion Profile date is based on baptism record
Mitchell-9217 H	1760	Sergeant Henry Mitchell		certain 8 Feb 1761 Albermarle Parish, Sussex County, Virginia	certain 17 May 1839 Sparta, Hancock, Georgia, USA	Male		WikiTree-24
Q96942474		Henry Mitchell (general in the American Revolutionary War (1760-1839))		1760	1839	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 14.11.2021 10:56:49 False suggestion wikidata source is SAR that says 'about 1760'; profile cites parish records for christening 8 Feb 1761 Richardson-7161 14.11.2021 14:02:19 False suggestion I do not use Wikidata, use sources
Bolling-14 H	1703	Jane Kennon Randolph (Bolling)		certain 23 Jul 1698 certain Cobbs, Henrico County, Colony of Virginia	before Jun 1767 certain Curles, Henrico County, Colony of Virginia	Female		Lunn-170 Meland-9 WikiTree-24
Q16738507		Jane Bolling ((1703-1766))		1703	1766	female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Rish-15 27.12.2017 02:59:10 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Madison-15 H	1663	John Madison Jr.		uncertain 1655 certain St. Stephens Parish, King and Queen County, Colony of Virginia	before 24 Mar 1726 certain St. Stephens Parish, King and Queen County, Colony of Virginia	Male		Gates-1691 WikiTree-24 WikiTree-6 Walter-2620
Q16859390		John Madison (American sheriff, planter, politician, and major landowner)		1663		male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-5956 01.10.2020 00:17:43 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Smyth-536 H	Jan 1580	Captain John Smith (Smyth) aka Smith		uncertain 2 Jan 1579 Willoughby, Lincolnshire, England	certain 21 Jun 1631 London, England	Male		WikiTree-24
Q228024		John Smith (English soldier, explorer, writer (1580–1631))		Jan 1580 Willoughby United Kingdom	21 Jun 1631 London United Kingdom	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Boy-41 01.12.2020 15:18:12 False suggestion Date is approximate and based on different sources
Croshaw-5 H	1610	Major Joseph Croshaw aka Chroshaw		uncertain 1612 uncertain	before 29 Jul 1667 certain Bruton Parish, James City, Colony of Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24
Q6282344		Joseph Croshaw (American planter)		1610	1667	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Parks-2399 26.12.2023 22:38:08 False suggestion
Field-1 H	1680	Mary Jefferson (Field)		certain 3 Feb 1679 Henrico County, Colony of Virginia	certain 13 Aug 1715 Henrico County, Colony of Virginia	Female		WikiTree-6 WikiTree-24
Q75766914		Mary Field ((1680-1715))		1680	1715	female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-5956 11.12.2019 20:28:44 False suggestion Unsourced data on WikiData/ThePeerage Lee-5956 11.12.2019 20:30:23 False suggestion birth record is being used, not ThePeerage/WikiData Clawson-1056 17.06.2020 03:03:22 False suggestion birthdate is an estimate on both wikitree and wikidata.
Washington-205 H	1696	Mildred Willis (Washington) aka Gregory, Lewis		1697 Fredericksburg, Spotsylvania County, Colony of Virginia	5 Sep 1747 Fredericksburg, Spotsylvania County, Colony of Virginia	Female		Koch-1533 Reed-10133 WikiTree-24 Dreyer-373 Nason-491
Q76240872		Mildred Washington ((1696-1747))		1696	1747	female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 20.04.2022 16:23:20 False suggestion False - different Mildred
Randolph-9 H	1691	Colonel Richard Randolph		2 May 1686 Turkey Island, Henrico County, Colony of Virginia	17 Dec 1748 Bath, Somerset, England	Male		WikiTree-24 Price-5385 Athey-67
Q7328595		Richard Randolph (American politician)		1691	1749	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Rish-15 06.09.2017 01:49:46 False suggestion Dates are correct on profile Rish-15 12.09.2017 14:56:04 False suggestion Other dates are just guessed years.
Lee-318 H	1617	Col. Richard The Immigrant Lee		before 22 Mar 1618 Worcester, Worcestershire, England	certain 1 Mar 1664 certain Dividing Creek, Northumberland, Colony of Virginia	Male		Quattlebaum-131 Wolfe-522 WikiTree-24 WikiTree-6 Darnell-283
Q7327313		Richard Lee I (American politician)		1617 Shropshire United Kingdom	1664 Virginia United States of America	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-5956 16.10.2019 22:03:53 False suggestion wikidata has no source, wikitree is based on christening record
Beverley-3 H	1696	Colonel William Beverley		before 31 Oct 1698 Beverley Park, King and Queen County, Virginia	certain 28 Feb 1756 Blandfield, St. Anne's Parish, Essex County, Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24 Christophel D'Errico-1
Q18714026		William Beverley (American legislator, civil servant, planter, and landowner)		1696 Colony of Virginia Colony of Virginia Kingdom of England Kingdom of Great Britain	1756 Virginia United States of America	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Wood-8367 26.06.2020 14:37:13 False suggestion WikiData is wrong. Father's bio says b 1698. William's bio says b 1696. Parents m 1697. Mother died 1698.