Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 575: FindAGrave - Different birth date (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information .

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Gaither-3 H	1644	Captain John Gaither II		before 1646 certain Colony of Virginia	before 12 Nov 1702 Abington, All Hallows Parish, Anne Arundel County, Province of Maryland	Male		WikiTree-24 Day-1904 Gray-3563
34075184		Capt John Gaither II		1644 Virginia, USA	1702 South River, Anne Arundel County, Maryland, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Thiessen-117 26.04.2019 16:46:38 False suggestion FindAGrave is estimate
Hanks-9 H	1600	Thomas The Immigrant Hanks aka Hancks, Hankes		before 1625 England	uncertain 8 Apr 1674 certain Gloucester County, Virginia	Male		Atherton-478 WikiTree-24 Robison-113 Maddox-1056
44326787		Thomas Jonathan Hanks III		1600 Stow-on-the-Wold, Cotswold District, Gloucestershire, England	8 Apr 1674 Gloucester County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-5956 24.10.2018 20:30:08 False suggestion FindAGrave is totally unsourced and contrary to documentation on profile
Price-171 H	1584	John Price		uncertain 1586 Manafon, Montgomeryshire, Wales	Sep 1628 Charles City, Colony of Virginia	Male		Douglass-990 Atkins-2361 WikiTree-24
33482782		John Price		1584 Montgomery, Powys, Wales	Sep 1628 Henrico County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 27.02.2022 00:04:09 False suggestion No gravestone image or source on FindAGrave
Teague-9 H	1655	Edward Teague aka Tegg		uncertain 1660 uncertain England	uncertain 9 Mar 1697 Teggs Delight, Cecil County, Province of Maryland	Male		WikiTree-24 Stanton-3574 Campbell-29890 Hamilton-1514 Poole-314 Mitchell-6301
109777081		Edward Teague		1655 Somerset, England	9 Mar 1697 Cecil County, Maryland, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Charles-1548 30.05.2017 03:03:14 False suggestion DoB is unsourced Charles-1548 30.05.2017 03:05:50 Comment
Awbrey-1 H	1665	Mary Awbrey		uncertain 1678 uncertain Rappahannock County, Colony of Virginia	uncertain 17 Oct 1721 uncertain Essex County, Colony of Virginia	Female		Knott-279 WikiTree-24
86154176		Mary Francis Awbrey Meador		1665 Essex County, Virginia, USA	17 Oct 1721 Essex County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Knott-279 30.08.2017 15:41:36 False suggestion This has already been been defined as a false error because Find A Grave is wrong -- no sources, not reliable
Royall-2 H	2 Jul 1600	Captain Joseph Royall		uncertain 1602 Canterbury, Kent, England	before 10 Mar 1656 certain Charles City County, Colony of Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24 Watson-58
64654515		Joseph Royall		2 Jul 1600 City of Canterbury, Kent, England	10 Mar 1654 Charles City County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 19.03.2019 21:34:36 False suggestion text of WikiTree has date with citation
Taylor-679 H	12 Feb 1634	James Taylor I		uncertain 1635 uncertain England	certain 30 Apr 1698 uncertain King and Queen County, Colony of Virginia	Male		WikiTree-6 WikiTree-24 Wolfe-522 Heierle-1
18538665		James “The Elder” Taylor I		12 Feb 1634 Carlisle, City of Carlisle, Cumbria, England	30 Apr 1698 Bowling Green, Caroline County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-5956 01.04.2017 19:08:59 False suggestion There are NO SOURCES for his birth as many, many genealogists indicate. His birth is merely a GUESS. With the birth year on FindAGrave, his age at the birth of his children seems old, whereas the estimate on the profile seems to be more likely. I am posting that if anyone wants to change the data on the profile, this is acceptable, as no dates are proven.
Bolling-8 H	25 Jan 1682	Major Robert Bolling Jr		25 Jan 1683 Charles City County, Colony of Virginia	17 Jul 1749 Kippax, Prince George County, Colony of Virginia	Male		Doughman-1 Draper-310 WikiTree-24
28777161		MAJ Robert “Robin” Bolling II		25 Jan 1682 Hopewell City, Virginia, USA	23 Jan 1747 Prince George County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 28.04.2021 19:02:20 False suggestion born 1682/3 - in datafield, wikitree guidance is to use 'new style' year (e.g., 1683, not 1682)
Croshaw-5 H	1610	Major Joseph Croshaw aka Chroshaw		uncertain 1612 uncertain	before 29 Jul 1667 certain Bruton Parish, James City, Colony of Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24
256556419		Major Joseph Croshaw		1610 York County, Virginia, USA	1667 York County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Parks-2399 26.12.2023 22:38:51 False suggestion
Blevins-39 H	27 Nov 1691	William Blevins		uncertain 1690 uncertain		Male		WikiTree-24 McClain-3310
138311887		William “Old Bill” Blevins II		27 Nov 1691 Lancashire, England	17 Feb 1771 Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 25.05.2021 01:03:15 False suggestion no source on findagrave McClain-3310 25.05.2021 01:03:48 False suggestion FindAGrave memorial is unsourced & likely incorrect; see Research Notes.
Blevins-40 H	1710	Mary Walling (Blevins)		uncertain 1712 certain Westerly, Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations	after 1750 uncertain Halifax County, Colony of Virginia	Female		McClain-3310 WikiTree-24
229874938		Mary Blevins Walling		1710	Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 19.11.2021 18:33:07 False suggestion FindAGrave record is unsourced. McClain-3310 19.11.2021 18:33:16 False suggestion
Walling-19 H	1732	Elisha Walling aka Wallen, Walden		uncertain 1734 certain Prince George's County, Colony of Maryland	certain Jan 1814 certain Irondale, Washington, Missouri, United States	Male		Bacon-1754 Wilson-33142 McClain-3310 McKinney-561 WikiTree-24
64163735		Elisha “The Longhunter” Walling / Wallen		1732 Prince George's County, Maryland, USA	Jan 1814 Washington County, Missouri, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Charles-1548 25.07.2018 18:27:06 False suggestion
Lee-1662 H	11 Mar 1695	John Lee Esq		uncertain 1690 uncertain Colony of Virginia	uncertain 1767 certain Mill Creek, Johnston County, Province of North Carolina	Male		WikiTree-24 Cobb-4561 Smith-153774 Miles-436 Wilkins-877 Good-1254
98353534		CPT John Lee Sr.		11 Mar 1695 Nansemond, Suffolk City, Virginia, USA	4 Dec 1766 Johnston County, North Carolina, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Leger-741 28.09.2019 03:46:29 False suggestion no source on findagrave Leger-741 08.08.2020 08:53:42 Comment Conflated parents Leger-741 29.04.2021 20:29:59 False suggestion no source on findagrave
Strother-64 H	1 Aug 1700	Lt. Col. Francis Strother		uncertain 1695 certain King George, King George County, Colony of Virginia	uncertain 1752 certain Culpeper County, Colony of Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24 WikiTree-6
98657597		Francis Strother Sr.		1 Aug 1700 King George County, Virginia, USA	17 Apr 1751 Culpeper County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-5956 08.11.2018 18:21:24 False suggestion There are no records proving his birth, this is an estimate
Dabney-32 H	1702	Susannah Strother (Dabney)		uncertain 1692 certain Pamunkey River Area, King and Queen County, Colony of Virginia	uncertain 1752 certain Culpeper County, Colony of Virginia	Female		WikiTree-24 Gómez Rossi-1 Elliott-4170 WikiTree-6
121220971		Susannah Dabney Strother		1702 Hanover County, Virginia, USA	1752
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-5956 11.08.2020 02:15:53 False suggestion Profile addresses all the incorrect parents out there
Coleman-708 H	16 Aug 1620	Col. Robert of Mobjack Bay Coleman		uncertain Sep 1622 certain Brent Eleigh, Suffolk, England	uncertain Dec 1688 uncertain Charles City, Charles City County, Colony of Virginia	Male		Coleman-1583 Pringle-583 WikiTree-24
134491215		CPT Robert Coleman Sr.		16 Aug 1620 England	Aug 1689 Gloucester County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lenover-1 28.03.2024 21:25:50 False suggestion multiple accounts of birth
Cheney-405 H	14 Jun 1616	Richard Cheney Sr. aka Cheyney, Chaney		uncertain 1621 uncertain England or Colony of Virginia	certain 6 Mar 1685 Anne Arundel County, Province of Maryland	Male		Day-1904 WikiTree-24
104482863		Richard Cheney		14 Jun 1616 Greater London, England	6 Mar 1685 South River, Anne Arundel County, Maryland, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Foster-86 27.04.2020 00:01:55 False suggestion FindAGrave is estimate
Gillespie-398 H	1730	James Gillespie		uncertain 1736 uncertain Ireland	1792 certain Blount County, Tennessee, United States	Male		WikiTree-24
224810911		James Gillespie Jr.		1730	1800
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Scarborough-638 19.01.2024 21:39:45 False suggestion
Zimmerman-639 H	1736	Peter Carpenter (Zimmerman)		uncertain 1738 certain Cocalico Township, Lancaster, Pennsylvania	certain Apr 1817 certain Lincoln, North Carolina, United States	Male		WikiTree-24
68365416		Peter Zimmerman Carpenter		1736 Cocalico, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA	Apr 1817 Lincoln County, North Carolina, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Simmons-11603 19.02.2022 01:08:35 Not corrected No source available currently for exact DOB, even findagrave lists '1736-40?' Simmons-11603 24.04.2022 23:39:41 False suggestion See comment, findagrave writes a range of dates
Finley-336 H	2 Jan 1743	George Finley		before 4 Jan 1748 Colony of Virginia	after 1809 Wayne County, Kentucky, USA	Male		WikiTree-24
8062484		George Finley		2 Jan 1743 Augusta County, Virginia, USA	22 Aug 1809 Wayne County, Kentucky, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 18.11.2021 07:07:46 False suggestion two different George Finleys are conflated in the FindAGrave memorial

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Sherwood-521 H	1662	Martha Thompson (Sherwood) aka Marshall		uncertain 1670 Sittenburne Parish, Old Rappahannock County, Colony of Virginia	before 26 Nov 1719 Westmoreland County, Colony of Virginia	Female		Hollis-1312 WikiTree-24 Maryanow-1
140001904		Martha Sherwood Marshall		1662 Rappahannock County, Virginia, USA	4 Jul 1749 Culpeper County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Downey-1809 21.10.2023 20:16:49 False suggestion birth dates on profile and findagrave are just guessed. no sources.
Lound-17 H	1650	Mary Batte (Lound) aka Lounds, Bates		before 1644 Yorkshire, England	uncertain 10 Sep 1720 Prince George County, Virginia	Female		Mounger-571 WikiTree-24 Foster-6835 Bora-11
66457860		Mary Lound Batte		1650 Henrico County, Virginia, USA	1727 Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 25.04.2020 19:37:03 False suggestion wikitree has source - she died before 10 Sep 1720
Browne-860 H	1598	Colonel Henry Browne		uncertain 1600 certain England	uncertain 1662 Surry County, Colony of Virginia	Male		WikiTree-24 Harrison-7836 Williams-4586
77040032		COL Henry Browne		1598	1661 Surry County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 02.12.2021 22:31:06 False suggestion No gravestone image on FindAGrave memorial
Banister-60 H	1689	John Banister		after 1687 Charles City County, Colony of Virginia	1755 Prince George County, Colony of Virginia	Male		Ramos-482 WikiTree-24
160996234		CPT John Banister		1689 Charles City County, Virginia, USA	1755 Prince George County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 27.08.2019 19:21:27 False suggestion no source for information in FindAGrave memorial
Mullins-655 H	1767	James Booker Booker Old Booker, Grandsire Mullins		uncertain 1762 uncertain North Carolina	certain 4 Apr 1864 certain Pound, Wise County, Virginia, United States	Male		Smith-59111 Frazier-2032 WikiTree-24
33946827		James Booker Adkins Mullins Sr.		1767 Franklin County, Virginia, USA	4 Apr 1864 Wise County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 27.04.2019 00:23:07 False suggestion note on profile says the FindAGrave memorial has errors & should not be useed as a source
Greer-614 H	1654	James Greer aka Grear, Greear, Greyer		before 1656 certain	before 1700 certain Province of Maryland	Male		WikiTree-24 McClain-3310
115761859		James Greer		1654 Dumfries and Galloway, Scotland	1688 Gunpowder Farms, Harford County, Maryland, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Carruth-363 26.10.2020 00:11:00 False suggestion birthdate is unsourced on Find a Grave and wikitree
Blevins-255 H	1718	William Blevins		uncertain 1720 uncertain Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations	after 1778	Male		McClain-3310 WikiTree-24 Worley-662
138312488		William “Captain” Blevins		1718 Washington County, Maryland, USA	17 Feb 1777 Sullivan County, Tennessee, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 20.09.2021 17:23:09 False suggestion No source cited on Find a Grave memorial
Blevins-257 H	1716	John Blevins		uncertain 1718 Westerly, Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations	after 1788 Sullivan, Southwest Territory, United States	Male		WikiTree-24 McClain-3310 Vargas-60 Burner-134
138312379		John “Jack” Blevins		1716 Virginia, USA	18 Oct 1805 Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 19.11.2021 18:34:15 False suggestion FindAGrave record is unsourced.
Taylor-11711 H	1629	John the Elder Taylor		before 1626 uncertain England	before 5 Apr 1676 certain Gunpowder, Baltimore County, Province of Maryland	Male		McClain-3310 WikiTree-24
116121735		John Taylor Sr.		1629 England	5 Apr 1676 Gunpowder, Baltimore County, Maryland, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment McClain-3310 10.02.2024 20:59:03 False suggestion No gravestone or source for birth date on Find A G
Batte-59 H	1669	Martha Peterson (Batte)		1688 Bristol Parish, Prince George County, Colony of Virginia	15 Jan 1758 Charles City, Charles County, Colony of Virginia	Female		Gardiner-1534 WikiTree-24 Atkinson-2575 Foster-6835
67166635		Mary Batte Peterson		1669 Charles City County, Virginia, USA	Isle of Wight County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 16.08.2017 05:47:50 False suggestion see note/warning in WikiTree profile's text
Sevier-76 H	1 Feb 1712	Valentine Sevier Sr. aka Xavier		certain 1 Feb 1713 certain St. Giles Parish, Cripplegate, London, England	certain 30 Dec 1803 certain Elizabethton, Carter, Tennessee, United States	Male		Dewdney-22 Rowland-3946 Matlock-353 WikiTree-24
7443100		Valentine “The Immigrant” Sevier Sr.		1 Feb 1712 Greater London, England	30 Dec 1803 Carter, Carter County, Tennessee, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lee-2164 01.12.2021 13:31:53 Corrected Dewdney-22 20.12.2022 19:51:49 False suggestion
Shuffert-3 H	14 Nov 1732	Anna Catherine Catarina Klein (Shuffert) aka Schufferd, Cline		after 28 Sep 1733 Pennsylvania	after 1783 Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, United States	Female		Ervin-353 WikiTree-24
39890019		Anna Catherine Schuffert Cline		14 Nov 1732 Lorraine, France	12 Mar 1798 Cabarrus County, North Carolina, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 27.12.2021 21:36:49 False suggestion indications are that she was born after her parents arrived in Virginia - in 1733 Noland-165 28.12.2021 04:21:30 False suggestion
Doak-197 H	16 Mar 1707	Thankful Finley (Doak)		after 1720 uncertain	after 1791 Augusta, Virginia, United States	Female		Bain-1212 Spratlin-29 WikiTree-24 Finley-1431
80509844		Thankful Doak		16 Mar 1707 Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland	20 Sep 1791 Augusta County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Finley-2811 13.07.2022 05:00:52 Corrected Downey-1809 15.10.2023 21:16:19 False suggestion no source
Munford-60 H	22 Sep 1734	Elizabeth Banister (Munford)		uncertain 27 Sep 1733 Prince George County, Colony of Virginia	uncertain 1770 Petersburg, Dinwiddie County, Colony of Virginia	Female		Ramos-482 WikiTree-24
161097707		Elizabeth Munford Banister		22 Sep 1734 Prince George County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 29.04.2021 23:35:15 False suggestion the FindAGrave memorial has both dates (27 Sep 1733 in text; 22 Sep 1734 in the top part) - no source found for either
Unknown-307442 H	1593	Jane Martiau (Unknown)		uncertain 1595 uncertain England	before 1640 uncertain York County, Colony of Virginia	Female		WikiTree-24
103549785		Elizabeth Jane Page Martiau		1593	1640 Yorktown, York County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Lenover-1 16.06.2019 00:39:45 False suggestion BIrth date is uncertain
Neel-899 H	7 Mar 1769	James Neel Esq		uncertain 1746	certain 5 Jul 1809 certain Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, United States	Male		Sheppard-2686 WikiTree-24
45187690		James Neel		7 Mar 1769 Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, USA	5 Jul 1809 Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Sheppard-2686 21.03.2019 14:50:46 Not corrected f-a-g is only a possible no proof Sheppard-2686 28.04.2019 01:55:24 Not corrected f-a-g is only a possible no proof Sheppard-2686 07.06.2019 22:57:30 False suggestion DoB is unsourced
Unknown-517094 H	1637	Lucretia Lues Burnett (Unknown)		uncertain 1635	before 10 Oct 1709 certain South Farnham Parish, Essex County, Colony of Virginia	Female		Kromer-183 WikiTree-24
122064389		Lucretia "Lues" Burnett		1637	Oct 1709 Essex County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Kromer-183 28.04.2023 23:43:22 False suggestion
Unknown-519941 H	1615	Rebecca Izard (Unknown) aka Bagnall		uncertain 1613 uncertain London, Middlesex, England	before 20 Oct 1675 Isle of Wight, Colony of Virginia	Female		St. Denis-47 WikiTree-24 Smith-32867 Carson-514
71082198		Rebecca Permentier Bagnall Izard		1615 France	20 Oct 1675 Isle of Wight County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Smith-32867 06.08.2020 15:45:23 False suggestion both are estimates; and FindAGrave is not reliable